Cudahy Car Rentals

Pick-up
Noon
Drop-off
Noon
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none

Cudahy car rental reviews and directory

Alamo
alamo
Car rental reviews:
Excellent (8.4, 16 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Alamo
Locations in Cudahy
5300 South Howell Avenue
+1 414 483 9800
  • 8.3
  • 8.9
  • 8.4
  • 8.5
  • 7.9
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent
Oct 18 2015
easy at milwaukee
Pros: courteous service, good car, fast in and out
8.0 Good
Oct 19 2015
Super Happy With my experience
Pros: Easy, clean, good to go!
6.4 Good
Nov 7 2015
Not the kind of car I paid for.
Pros: Car was clean, pickup was pretty fast.
Cons: I thought I was getting a Toyota Corolla (an intermediate). Instead I got a Chevy Cruz (a compact of lower quality).
2.0 Poor
Nov 28 2015
Cons: I couldn't rent a car because Alamo wouldn't accept debit cards. If i was flying then they would accept debit cards. I don't have a credit card.
10.0 Excellent
Dec 17 2015
Pros: Brand new car
10.0 Excellent
Dec 18 2015
Pros: Everything was ready. Quick set up and go. Car was clean and no surprises.
7.6 Good
Dec 23 2015
Fine print
Pros: Car was great, man working behind counter was clearly cranky. My biggest surprise was that the car did not have unlimited mileage which luckily we stayed under but only because we motified our trip. We travel all over the world and often for business as well and never had these restrictions. Didn't see any warning upon booking about this restriction either:(
7.2 Good
Jan 12 2016
Pros: Crazy that I can fly across the county for cheaper. Don't exactly understand pricing but car was comfortable.
Cons: Tires in bad weather.
10.0 Excellent
Feb 15 2016
Great service and great price
Pros: The pickup of vehicle was smooth and a great value
10.0 Excellent
Mar 1 2016
Pros: Not much to do- just return a car. -also relatively quick
Payless
payless
Car rental reviews:
Good (7.5, 11 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Payless
Locations in Cudahy
5300 S Howell Ave
+1 414 747 9545
  • 7.3
  • 7.6
  • 7.8
  • 7.3
  • 7.5
Recent reviews
9.2 Excellent
Oct 20 2015
Effectively painless
Pros: Nice car. Clean and plenty new. Drove well. Dropoff was easy. Girl who worked the counter was pleasant, but she spoke really fast and I had to ask her to repeat herself a few times (and I'm from NY!!!).
Cons: Girl at counter said the gas was cheaper at payless, so dropping the car with 3/4th empty would be better than filling it up before returning it. She charged me $38 and there's NO WAY that it was cheaper that way so I DEFINITELY felt duped. I told her there's no way it'd be cheaper but she said it would be. THAT is a problem. Short of that, the only real issue was finding the car; it was a bit of a maze but not too bad.
10.0 Excellent
Oct 28 2015
A Good Deal
Pros: We got a very good rate. No hidden fees or pressure for useless "services". When we arrived, some other rental desks were packed with long waits. Payless had only us as a customer, which was nice and quick for us. But I worried that it might not bode well - why didn't they have other customers? But service both for pick up and return was quick, the car was great, clean, and a good ride. Quieter than our more expensive car.
9.6 Excellent
Nov 24 2015
Decent vehicle for the money
Pros: Clean and functional, decent price. Had a Kia Soul with 30,000+ miles on it. Nothing special but it was all we needed.
Cons: Not much
10.0 Excellent
Dec 16 2015
Pleasant Experience
Pros: At MKE: Staff at counter for pickup and dropoff were friendly, helpful, and efficient. Car was clean and ready to go at designated time.
Cons: MKE: more signage in the garage would be helpful.
6.0 Okay
Dec 21 2015
Bad customer service at the counter
Pros: The Payless customer service representative behaved like she had never worked in sales. In short she behaved like a jerk, short answers, bad tone, very inquisitive. Maybe having a bad day but that is not an excuse to behave badly with customers.
5.6 Okay
Dec 30 2015
Pros: The price was good!
Cons: I had to wait about 40 minute to pick up my car since no rentals were available at the time, although it was 30 minutes past my scheduled pick up time. When I returned the car, the computer system was not working so I still haven't received a receipt or confirmation of charges a day later.
2.0 Poor
Jan 24 2016
Twrrible experience, will never rent from here aga
Cons: Smelled like smoke during initial inspection even with the no smoking policy, radio signal barely worked, electrical outlets did not work, car needed realignment, dirty with hair all over the head rests, cigarette burn holes all over back seat, exterior damage check was done in the dark so we were unable to properly assess for damage before rental, when talked with people at service counter the excuse was that their managers were new as well as didnt care and the service agent was unable to do anything about our complaints. We will NEVER rent from payless again
10.0 Excellent
Feb 2 2016
Pros: Destiny at the front desk was extremely friendly and helpful
10.0 Excellent
Feb 19 2016
Pros: Customer service on return, that's the service ever.
Cons: N/A
4.0 Mediocre
Apr 9 2016
Fucking bullshit
Cons: The car was uncomfortable and there were a bunch of hidden fees.
Budget
budget
Car rental reviews:
Good (7.2, 10 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Budget
Locations in Cudahy
5300 South Howell Avenue
+1 414 481 2411
  • 7.2
  • 7.8
  • 8.0
  • 6.6
  • 6.4
Recent reviews
5.6 Okay
Oct 21 2015
"Fuel Service" Fee is Extortion
Cons: Their "Fuel Service" fee is extortion. It doesn't show up in the quote but you have to pay it to rent the car. I'll never rent from Budget again.
6.0 Okay
Nov 23 2015
Cons: They did not have the size car I reserved and offered me a smaller car for no less money. I ended up in a mini-van....yuck!!!
7.2 Good
Nov 29 2015
Pros: Dropping off the car was fast.
Cons: Picking up the car was slow.
5.2 Okay
Nov 30 2015
Cons: Stayed one extra day and was charged full rate for the entire trip. Ridiculous.
8.4 Excellent
Nov 30 2015
Pros: Quickly processed return.
Cons: A little confusion as to where the car was to be dropped off once I entered the parking garage. Signage needs a little improvement.
10.0 Excellent
Dec 10 2015
Pros: friendly helpful staff, exceptional actually
2.0 Poor
Jan 29 2016
Worst rental experience ever
Pros: Nothing
Cons: Waited 49 minutes and they stil had no car. Was late to my destination and they were rude and unhelpful. All this with a sign on the counter saying "cars available". I will never use them again
10.0 Excellent
Apr 19 2016
Pros: RAV4 was an excellent choice & came a a great rate - had bluetooth audio and EcoMode to sip gas.
Cons: As with all rental car companies, they try to upsell the non-essentials, so that's annoying
7.6 Good
May 2 2016
Pros: Cleanliness and the choice of cars was awesome! Very friendly service during pick up!
Cons: Very confusing on how to return the truck and the staff was very rude! I won't refer my friends to Budget at all.
10.0 Excellent
Jun 27 2016
Pros: The customer service was outstanding
Cons: The customer service line was long
Ace
ace
Car rental reviews:
Good (6.9, 5 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Ace
Locations in Cudahy
2727 E Layton Avenue
1-414-489-6600
  • 7.2
  • 6.8
  • 6.8
  • 6.0
  • 7.6
Recent reviews
2.0 Poor
Oct 16 2015
Scam pricing
Pros: Nothing
Cons: We arrived at the counter, after a long shuttle ride from the terminal, and were told that Ace does not accept third party credit card insurance and that we must buy theirs - at $25 a day! We cancelled our reservation on the spot but were still charged $25 on our credit card. Never again.
7.2 Good
Nov 15 2015
Pros: the pick up was ok
Cons: the dropoff was too slow. need more people to attend
9.6 Excellent
Jan 17 2016
Cheapest rental car in my area
Pros: Was no problem for me to extend the reservation another day. Employees were very nice. Lowest price I could find for unlimited mileage. Do remember to bring your car insurance card, even if you think it won't cover the rental. The employee checked for even the tiniest damage before I took the car, and I returned it dirty due to driving through bad weather, so I was worried I was going to get charged. However, there were no additional charges upon return.
Cons: Was really part of Mayfair Rent-A-Car, at least in the Milwaukee office. This made it a little hard to find. They were going to charge me $5 for gas because the needle was not past the Full mark, but I said I filled up just around the corner and I filled it up until it was spilling out. No charge once I mentioned that. I did get a speeding ticket in the car and the registration was nowhere to be found, which made the officer unhappy.
6.4 Good
Feb 10 2016
Don't have a support animal
Pros: I liked that she upgraded me to a truck because it snowed.
Cons: I don't like how they charged me to clean out pet hair. When I have a Dr. Note saying he has to be with me, and that's normal wear and tear, when driving.
9.2 Excellent
Mar 3 2016
Pros: The fast friendly service and the availability of cars. Easy to search and find. The people seem to enjoy their job which made it pleasant me.
Cons: I didnt like the feel of the driver head rest. I was not that comfortable me.
Avis
avis
Car rental reviews:
Excellent (8.8, 2 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Avis
Locations in Cudahy
5300 South Howell Avenue
+1 414 482 8345
  • 9.0
  • 9.0
  • 9.0
  • 7.0
  • 10.0
Recent reviews
8.0 Good
Mar 7 2016
Early morning dropoff issues
Cons: I was very confused about how to do the drop off at 5:30am at the airport. No clear instructions or help available.
9.6 Excellent
Apr 2 2016
Really nice brand new van
Pros: The van we rented was brand new, only 77 miles, with the dvd system. It was very nice and well worth the money for use for traveling with two teenagers! This was my first time using Kayak and it was very easy. I will use it again.
Enterprise
enterprise
Car rental reviews:
Poor (2.0, 1 reviews)
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
3 locations
Enterprise
Locations in Cudahy
4747 S Howell Ave
4144818888
5300 S Howell Ave
+1 414 294 5880
4142945880
  • 2.0
  • 2.0
  • 2.0
  • 2.0
  • 2.0
Recent reviews
2.0 Poor
Jul 28 2016
Lousy customer care
Pros: I liked that I could go online and secure a rental.
Cons: I didn't like that there was an attempt to take money off my card for the rental ahead of time even though the site said that I could pay when I picked up the rental. I didn't get the rental cause I needed a major credit card. The site doesn't tell you this. Had I had enough money in my account for the rental and then couldn't get the rental I don't know how much time it would have taken to get my money back. The agent at Enterprise said that they don't know what is on Kayak or price lines site and could not help me.
Mayfair
hertz
Car rental locations in Cudahy:
1 location
Mayfair
Locations in Cudahy
2727 E Layton Ave
1-414-489-6600
45 travelers who rented a car in Cudahy gave the car agency they used an average rating of 7.6

Car Rental Locations in Cudahy

Cudahy
Close
Would you like to save as your currency permanently or for this visit only?
Close