Find Cheap Flights from Reykjavik to New York (IS1 - NYC)

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York

Sat 2/24
Sat 3/3
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Book cheap flights from Reykjavik to New York (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
Reykjavik
$230
only
$230
Destination
New York
$474
only
$474
$270
only
$270
Newark
$230
only
$230
Wed, May 2
KEF
EWR
6h 20m
Mon, May 14
EWR
KEF
6h 15m
Trip: 13 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Good 6.3

Low price, Iceland stopover, very modern and cool looking airplanes

Low-cost airline! No (free) food and movies on the plain, small legroom and every piece of luggage costs extra, even though it seems that the carry on luggage payment is not strictly enforced. Need to be prepared for that (bring your own movies or a book and buy food at the airport or just don't come hungry :-)

KEF
EWR
Mediocre 2.6

Kudos to the pilot, the flight was great! I can’t comment on food and entertainment due to my family and I having our own .

having to rush through customs in order to catch our connecting flight... wasn’t able to shop duty free... plane very uncomfortable... flight delayed

KEF
EWR
Excellent 9.3

The flight attendants were friendly. The price was great

Got a chicken sandwich that cost $10 and only had one slice of meat. A very thin slice. It tasted good but not worth spending the money.

KEF
EWR
Good 6.0

Didn’t even provide water free of charge. That’s ridiculous

KEF
EWR
Good 7.5

new planes, pleasant crew. on time.

Passengers told to board then stand in glass jet way for a long time in very hot conditions before plane could be entered.

Thu, Aug 9
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Mon, Aug 27
JFK
KEF
5h 35m
Trip: 19 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Sat, Jul 28
KEF
JFK
5h 54m
Sun, Aug 12
JFK
KEF
5h 45m
Trip: 16 days
7.8GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.8 Good
Based on 1756 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.7
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.1
Food
7.4
DMM
AMS
Okay 5.6

Tiny old cramped plane.

IAD
AMS
Good 7.3

787 is a great airplane. The 3-3-3 seat configuration leaves enough seat width to be just comfortable in coach.

LAX
AMS
Mediocre 2.0

My bagage broke

I paid extra fee for extra bagage which was tv and i paid insurance my tv broke and no one responces for it

AMS
NCL
Good 7.6

Pretty basic one hour flight so there's not much to complain about or praise about. I got some sleep which was good.

The crew had their general Dutch aloofness on form. Chatted to one of the stewardesses in Dutch up until she saw I had a British passport then she decided she could only speak English to me.

IAD
AMS
Mediocre 2.0

They stole my money

Fri, Jun 8
KEF
LGA
12h 03m
Mon, Jun 18
LGA
KEF
12h 40m
Trip: 11 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 21542 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.3
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
PHL
Good 6.5

so late. no explanation... something about the weather bad in Boston? but that wouldn't explain every flight being late. And as usual Kayak did a better job of giving delay info than Air Canada!

YVR
ICN
Good 7.3

I liked the entertainment. The crew was very attentive.

One of the meals wasn’t extremely desirable.

ATL
YYZ
Okay 5.0

I arrived safely

I didn't appreciate losing my luggage as I came to Canada for a wedding and I didn't have access to my things. The flight was direct so I don't understand why my luggage was lost.

YYC
LHR
Mediocre 2.0

JustFly did not release my coupon to Lufthansa or Air Canada, and so I was nearly prevented from flying.

YUL
ORD
Excellent 9.6

Friendliness of staff My familly got to follow my flight very closely.

Delays and harsh trubulance (altough i know that wasn’t air Canada’s fault for the weather) The changing of gates and the changing of boarding time without being updated on the application. The changing of the gate was changed moments before the boarding

Fri, Jun 8
KEF
EWR
6h 15m
Sun, Jun 17
EWR
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 10 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Good 6.0

Didn’t even provide water free of charge. That’s ridiculous

KEF
EWR
Okay 4.3

The staff was nice

I will not ever fly Wow again. I paid more than my friends did to get to Europe and they got meals and drinks as well as free baggage.

KEF
EWR
Good 6.3

Low price, Iceland stopover, very modern and cool looking airplanes

Low-cost airline! No (free) food and movies on the plain, small legroom and every piece of luggage costs extra, even though it seems that the carry on luggage payment is not strictly enforced. Need to be prepared for that (bring your own movies or a book and buy food at the airport or just don't come hungry :-)

KEF
EWR
Mediocre 2.6

Kudos to the pilot, the flight was great! I can’t comment on food and entertainment due to my family and I having our own .

having to rush through customs in order to catch our connecting flight... wasn’t able to shop duty free... plane very uncomfortable... flight delayed

KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

the crew wears handsome uniforms. Everyone looks nice.

Oh my god, I felt like a sardine. They developed their passenger seating scheme by carefully studying Iraqi prison torture manuals, I think. I didn't die but that outcome was surprising to me.

Thu, Mar 1
KEF
JFK
15h 30m
Wed, Mar 7
JFK
KEF
16h 55m
Trip: 7 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 2473 reviews
Boarding
7.1
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.6
Entertainment
7.0
Food
6.2
ARN
JFK
Excellent 10.0

My luggage was lost. Filed a case. Norwegian has no ide when I will get my suitcase.

JFK
ARN
Mediocre 2.0

It was very late and we missed out our opera tickets.

LAX
LGW
Okay 4.0

There was one particularly pretty crew member with a great laugh and she was very friendly

I flew out with the same luggage that I flew in with. They charged me $56 for it. It seemed as if they made a new rule out of the blue and included my personal bag my carry on. It wasn't that they had to be concerned about the FAA weight requirements because the flight was only about 80% full. The in-flight entertainment was limited and there was no audio... so in other words, you could not simply turn on music to go to sleep by. This is a very bare-bones airline. Also, one flight attendant was perhaps the rudest person I've ever come across. "Go talk to someone else - I'm busy." All I asked for was a fork. She was simply opening a bin at the moment.

BCN
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Please return my money.

Please return my money.

LAX
CDG
Okay 5.3

Flight on time

No food or pillow.comforter even long flight and everything is on sell

Tue, May 1
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Sat, May 5
JFK
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 5 days
5.6OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.6 Okay
Based on 1379 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
LGW
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing

Poor customer service

CDG
KEF
Good 6.4

Great legroom, nice crew.

The confusion about whether or not our flight was going to be on time was extremely stressful. Our first flight got delayed 90 minutes and our second flight got moved up 30 minutes, so our two hour delay shrunk to 0 minutes. The flight crew in Paris had no information about whether or not they were going to hold our flight, and we all sprinted through the airport in Iceland to board our second flight.

ORD
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing!

Everything! Flight was cancelled, only could get us on another flight 3 days later then that flight was delayed! Wth!

BOS
KEF
Excellent 8.0

Lovely planes, crew, airports. All went well.

Would have preferred ceiling lights to have been completely dimmed during night flying. Would have preferred ramp (walk-on/off) exits at all airports.

EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.6

Food/drinks are overpriced. Seats are too small. There’s no entertainment for long haul flights. Water isn’t even served. The front desk was very dismissive of any customer service when our plane was late.

Wed, Jun 6
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Tue, Jun 12
JFK
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 7 days
5.6OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.6 Okay
Based on 1379 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
AMS
Mediocre 3.0

The flight was held when our previous flight was delayed so no rebooking was necessary.

CDG
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

No luggage included.

EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

The plane did not arrive. Could not book for next days flight. Now they are not refunding...

KEF
LGW
Mediocre 2.0

WOW airlines canceled my flight and won't refund my money

WOW airlines canceled my flight and won't refund my money

FRA
KEF
Good 6.0

The on board crew was friendly

Flights were late. I also did not like that they charge for everything. Maybe that is how most airlines are now, but I found it irritating.

Mon, Jul 2
KEF
EWR
6h 20m
Sat, Jul 21
EWR
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 20 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

the crew wears handsome uniforms. Everyone looks nice.

Oh my god, I felt like a sardine. They developed their passenger seating scheme by carefully studying Iraqi prison torture manuals, I think. I didn't die but that outcome was surprising to me.

KEF
EWR
Excellent 8.6

Nice clean aircraft. Pleasant flight.

Would like at least a drink of water without having to pay.

KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

I already emailed WOW customer service and have yet to receive a response. Please respond to my email as it has been past your typical turnaround time

KEF
EWR
Mediocre 2.6

Kudos to the pilot, the flight was great! I can’t comment on food and entertainment due to my family and I having our own .

having to rush through customs in order to catch our connecting flight... wasn’t able to shop duty free... plane very uncomfortable... flight delayed

KEF
EWR
Good 6.0

Didn’t even provide water free of charge. That’s ridiculous

Mon, Jun 4
KEF
LGA
9h 12m
Sun, Jun 10
LGA
KEF
10h 35m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Mon, Jul 2
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Sat, Jul 21
JFK
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 20 days
5.6OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.6 Okay
Based on 1379 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
AMS
Mediocre 3.0

The flight was held when our previous flight was delayed so no rebooking was necessary.

CDG
KEF
Good 6.4

Great legroom, nice crew.

The confusion about whether or not our flight was going to be on time was extremely stressful. Our first flight got delayed 90 minutes and our second flight got moved up 30 minutes, so our two hour delay shrunk to 0 minutes. The flight crew in Paris had no information about whether or not they were going to hold our flight, and we all sprinted through the airport in Iceland to board our second flight.

EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.6

Food/drinks are overpriced. Seats are too small. There’s no entertainment for long haul flights. Water isn’t even served. The front desk was very dismissive of any customer service when our plane was late.

CDG
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

No luggage included.

BOS
KEF
Excellent 8.0

Lovely planes, crew, airports. All went well.

Would have preferred ceiling lights to have been completely dimmed during night flying. Would have preferred ramp (walk-on/off) exits at all airports.

Mon, Jul 2
KEF
LGA
9h 12m
Sun, Jul 22
LGA
KEF
15h 35m
Trip: 21 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 21542 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.3
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
ATL
YYZ
Okay 5.0

I arrived safely

I didn't appreciate losing my luggage as I came to Canada for a wedding and I didn't have access to my things. The flight was direct so I don't understand why my luggage was lost.

YUL
YVR
Okay 4.3

Generous leg room in coach class

Sat on the runway for almost an hour both to and from my destination

YYZ
PHL
Good 6.5

so late. no explanation... something about the weather bad in Boston? but that wouldn't explain every flight being late. And as usual Kayak did a better job of giving delay info than Air Canada!

LAX
YYZ
Excellent 8.0

Plane delayed 1 hour and a half. No compensation.

YYC
YYZ
Good 7.5

ground crew were friendly

Tue, Jul 17
KEF
EWR
6h 15m
Fri, Jul 20
EWR
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 4 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Good 6.3

Low price, Iceland stopover, very modern and cool looking airplanes

Low-cost airline! No (free) food and movies on the plain, small legroom and every piece of luggage costs extra, even though it seems that the carry on luggage payment is not strictly enforced. Need to be prepared for that (bring your own movies or a book and buy food at the airport or just don't come hungry :-)

KEF
EWR
Okay 4.3

The staff was nice

I will not ever fly Wow again. I paid more than my friends did to get to Europe and they got meals and drinks as well as free baggage.

KEF
EWR
Good 7.5

That our flight wasnt cancelled. That our pilot landed us safely in the storm.

no entertainment no wifi

KEF
EWR
Good 6.0

Didn’t even provide water free of charge. That’s ridiculous

KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

I already emailed WOW customer service and have yet to receive a response. Please respond to my email as it has been past your typical turnaround time

Mon, Jun 4
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Sat, Jun 9
JFK
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 6 days
5.6OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.6 Okay
Based on 1379 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
BWI
Mediocre 2.3

Nothing

N/a

CDG
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

No luggage included.

EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

The plane did not arrive. Could not book for next days flight. Now they are not refunding...

ORD
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing!

Everything! Flight was cancelled, only could get us on another flight 3 days later then that flight was delayed! Wth!

FRA
KEF
Good 6.0

The on board crew was friendly

Flights were late. I also did not like that they charge for everything. Maybe that is how most airlines are now, but I found it irritating.

Mon, Jun 4
KEF
EWR
6h 20m
Sun, Jun 10
EWR
KEF
6h 15m
Trip: 7 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

I already emailed WOW customer service and have yet to receive a response. Please respond to my email as it has been past your typical turnaround time

KEF
EWR
Excellent 9.3

The flight attendants were friendly. The price was great

Got a chicken sandwich that cost $10 and only had one slice of meat. A very thin slice. It tasted good but not worth spending the money.

KEF
EWR
Good 7.5

new planes, pleasant crew. on time.

Passengers told to board then stand in glass jet way for a long time in very hot conditions before plane could be entered.

KEF
EWR
Excellent 8.6

Nice clean aircraft. Pleasant flight.

Would like at least a drink of water without having to pay.

KEF
EWR
Good 7.5

That our flight wasnt cancelled. That our pilot landed us safely in the storm.

no entertainment no wifi

Tue, Jul 17
KEF
JFK
6h 15m
Fri, Jul 20
JFK
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 4 days
5.6OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.6 Okay
Based on 1379 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.0

The plane did not arrive. Could not book for next days flight. Now they are not refunding...

KEF
AMS
Mediocre 3.0

The flight was held when our previous flight was delayed so no rebooking was necessary.

FRA
KEF
Good 6.0

The on board crew was friendly

Flights were late. I also did not like that they charge for everything. Maybe that is how most airlines are now, but I found it irritating.

EWR
KEF
Mediocre 2.6

Food/drinks are overpriced. Seats are too small. There’s no entertainment for long haul flights. Water isn’t even served. The front desk was very dismissive of any customer service when our plane was late.

KEF
LGW
Mediocre 2.0

WOW airlines canceled my flight and won't refund my money

WOW airlines canceled my flight and won't refund my money

Thu, Mar 1
KEF
LGA
10h 30m
Wed, Mar 7
LGA
KEF
11h 30m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, Aug 1
KEF
EWR
6h 20m
Wed, Aug 8
EWR
KEF
6h 15m
Trip: 8 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Excellent 8.6

Nice clean aircraft. Pleasant flight.

Would like at least a drink of water without having to pay.

KEF
EWR
Good 6.3

Low price, Iceland stopover, very modern and cool looking airplanes

Low-cost airline! No (free) food and movies on the plain, small legroom and every piece of luggage costs extra, even though it seems that the carry on luggage payment is not strictly enforced. Need to be prepared for that (bring your own movies or a book and buy food at the airport or just don't come hungry :-)

KEF
EWR
Excellent 10.0

The comfort of the entire flight.

Nothing!

KEF
EWR
Okay 4.3

The staff was nice

I will not ever fly Wow again. I paid more than my friends did to get to Europe and they got meals and drinks as well as free baggage.

KEF
EWR
Mediocre 2.6

Kudos to the pilot, the flight was great! I can’t comment on food and entertainment due to my family and I having our own .

having to rush through customs in order to catch our connecting flight... wasn’t able to shop duty free... plane very uncomfortable... flight delayed

Sun, Mar 4
KEF
JFK
19h 10m
Sat, Mar 10
JFK
KEF
19h 50m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Sat, Jul 21
KEF
EWR
6h 15m
Wed, Aug 1
EWR
KEF
6h 05m
Trip: 12 days
6.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.0 Good
Based on 51 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.2
Comfort
5.6
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
4.1
Food
4.7
KEF
EWR
Mediocre 2.6

Kudos to the pilot, the flight was great! I can’t comment on food and entertainment due to my family and I having our own .

having to rush through customs in order to catch our connecting flight... wasn’t able to shop duty free... plane very uncomfortable... flight delayed

KEF
EWR
Excellent 8.6

Nice clean aircraft. Pleasant flight.

Would like at least a drink of water without having to pay.

KEF
EWR
Excellent 9.3

The flight attendants were friendly. The price was great

Got a chicken sandwich that cost $10 and only had one slice of meat. A very thin slice. It tasted good but not worth spending the money.

KEF
EWR
Good 6.0

Didn’t even provide water free of charge. That’s ridiculous

KEF
EWR
Okay 5.0

I already emailed WOW customer service and have yet to receive a response. Please respond to my email as it has been past your typical turnaround time

Reykjavik to New York Flight Information

Avg. Flight Duration 6h 09m
Flights Arrive in New York
Flights Depart from Reykjavik
Flight Price $230
Distance 2610 miles
Airlines WOW air, KLM, Air Canada, Norwegian
*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

^
The fares displayed include all taxes and fees for economy class travel and were found by the provider in the last 72 hours. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights and days. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Some carriers charge additional fees for extra checked bags. Please check the carriers' sites.