Key West Car Rentals

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for car rental deals in Key West

Sat 12/9
Noon
Sun 12/10
Noon
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Key West car rental reviews and directory

Alamo
Car rental reviews:
Excellent (8.3, null reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Alamo
Locations in Key West
2516 N Roosevelt Blvd
+1 844 868 8503
  • 8.2
  • 8.1
  • 8.4
  • 7.9
  • 8.7
Recent reviews
10.0 Excellent
Jul 16 2016
Key West - Fast & Excellent Service
Pros: Showed up at Alamo's vehicle pickup center and was greeted before I even walked in the door. Thomas (the agent) got me on my way in less than 5 minutes - super friendly, and professional. I would highly recommend this Alamo for costumer service/satisfaction. Clean car, no issues.
4.0 Okay
Aug 29 2016
Tried to charge me twice, didnt honor same payment
Cons: Tried to charge me at pickup, and again at drop off. Also, made me place a $200 deposit to rent the car, when 5 days prior that was not a requirement.
4.0 Okay
Sep 12 2016
Extremely Inconvenient Pickup
Pros: The car itself was the only plus side of my pickup in Key West.
Cons: First of all, when I made my reservation it said the pick up was at the Key West airport (so I took a cab to the airport). Then I learned that I would have to wait for a shuttle (25 minutes in the rain) to another location. The second location was a dingy trailer with a single employee. That employee informed me that I needed plane ticket information to rent the car (I am a Florida resident and wasn't flying anywhere...this was a one-way rental). After he finally agrees to use my boat ticket (I have no idea why they needed this, I clearly was renting a car and not taking another form of transportation home), it turned out that the car I had originally rented needed an oil change. So they had to find another car. All in all, my pickup took about an hour and a half when it should have taken 10 minutes. Completely horrible experience.
10.0 Excellent
Sep 18 2016
Pros: Perfect
10.0 Excellent
Nov 23 2016
Great staff
Pros: Staff was great. Freindly and fast
10.0 Excellent
Dec 14 2016
Pros: The guys in key west are always super friendly and have great customer service skills!
5.2 Okay
Dec 16 2016
Pros: Agents were friendly and efficient.
Cons: Trash left in hatch area from previous client. Thought it was a bit pricey for what you received. The facilities were outside of the airport when all other rental companies were inside terminal. The rental facility was shoddy.
10.0 Excellent
Dec 18 2016
HORRIBLE!
Cons: Got up at 4am traveled 12 hrs. Exhausted went to pick up car. No record of reservation according to agent. Wanted more then twice what reservation was to get a car! NEVER AGAIN ALAMO!!!!!
10.0 Excellent
Dec 22 2016
Good points.
Pros: The paperwork at the drop-off point went smoothly. The post-inspection process went smoothly and was completed in a very short time.
8.4 Excellent
Dec 24 2016
Easy
Pros: The drop off was easy to find
Budget
Car rental reviews:
Good (7.1, 20 reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Budget
Locations in Key West
3495 South Roosevelt Road
+1 305 294 8868
  • 6.9
  • 7.2
  • 7.3
  • 7.2
  • 7.2
Recent reviews
2.0 Mediocre
May 5 2017
Cons: There was none there at 7:15 am on the drop off
10.0 Excellent
Oct 19 2015
Pros: They were very professional in the car was very clean very
10.0 Excellent
Nov 9 2015
Great Experience
Pros: Great Rate, good cars and no hassle
7.2 Good
Nov 15 2015
One Way to Jacksonville
Pros: The car was clean, reasonably comfortable and rode well. It got good gas mileage and the total trip cost approximately $20.00 in fuel.
Cons: If the car had cruise control I could not find it and rentals rarely if ever have an owners manual in the car. Cruise control is a definite plus for long distance.
6.0 Good
Nov 5 2016
Rushed dirt
Pros: The A1A drive in a convertible
Cons: The rushed service at pick up. They didn't go over a few details that would of been helpful. The car was filthy. Still not sure if I'm getting charged using the the passive pay pass on the Florida turnpike. Never explained so I turned it on and hoped it worked.
10.0 Excellent
Dec 24 2016
Great service
Pros: Definitely rent a car through Kayak/Budget again!
10.0 Excellent
Jan 18 2017
Customers Service
Pros: The customer service with Budget was great. Both of the reps I dealt with in person were kind, helpful and went above and beyond. I had to change my reservation and the rep on the phone made it seem less. I will definitely use Budget again!
2.0 Mediocre
Mar 30 2017
Pros: It was cancelled due to weather
10.0 Excellent
Apr 10 2017
Pros: Rep in Airport, Ping, was very courteous and prompt. I don't remember the nme of the agent in Cape Coral, (return) but he was outstanding. I rented a Malibu and got 40 MPH.
5.6 Okay
May 6 2017
Cons: Drop off was confusing. I didn't know where I was supposed to park and there was nobody to direct me
Hertz
hertz
Car rental reviews:
Good (6.9, 19 reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
2 locations
Hertz
Locations in Key West
3491 S. Roosevelt Blvd
+1 305 294 1039
5901 Nw 24 Way
9547713749
  • 6.5
  • 6.7
  • 6.5
  • 6.5
  • 6.3
Recent reviews
7.6 Good
Nov 9 2015
upgrade feels like a down grade
Pros: customer service was good
Cons: upgrade felt more like a down grade. I reserved a premium car that had a V6 and upgraded to to a SUV that had a four cylinder engine, it is the lack of power that felt like I was down graded.
8.0 Excellent
Jan 10 2017
Clean and mechanically sound
Pros: The car was clean, late model not too many miles. About what you'd expect. Only concern was The scuffs/paint from other cars on the front And rear bumper. Was not told about this Ahead of time was concerned they would think I caused the damage. I've experienced this With other rental companies my opinion is that Damage should be disclosed up front so as to Relieve the customer of any fear of being held Responsible for pre existing damage.
3.6 Mediocre
Jan 18 2017
Pros: Nothing.
Cons: I made a reservation and no cars were available. The experience was non-existent.
10.0 Excellent
Jan 28 2017
Pros: The final cost and car were just what we expected, thank you.
8.8 Excellent
Mar 25 2017
Pros: Rental location was perfect..., just outside the terminal.
Cons: This car did not have push button ignition and I ended up having to call Roadside Assistance to unlock the car because I inadvertent left the key on the seat and locked the door. I will never ever rent another car that does not have push button ignition... as this incident cost me $84 to get the car unlocked to retrieve the keys.
10.0 Excellent
Apr 28 2017
Happy
Pros: The small airport was crowded and several people were in line to get a car. The gentleman behind the desk was quick, very pleasant and well organized. We soon was on our way.
2.0 Mediocre
May 24 2017
No help.
Pros: I had booked the wrong pick up point for the car. My reservation was useless, they didn't even give the option of applying any of my prepaid reservation to the new one I had to make. My 40 rate went up to 240, then she offered 120. The new kiosks w/ an agent on a screen are awful. Terrible technology.
7.2 Good
May 25 2017
Cons: No good drop off point at this airport. We had to walk across and then walk all the way back to the other side of the airport. Car was not cleaned on the outside.
10.0 Excellent
Jun 21 2017
Pros: I enjoyed the convertible
6.8 Good
Nov 19 2017
Easy drop off
Pros: Super fast and easy drop off
Cons: Want much to comment on. All we did was drop the car off and that was super easy.
Avis
Car rental reviews:
Excellent (8.1, 11 reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Avis
Locations in Key West
3495 South Roosevelt Boulevard
+1 305 296 8744
  • 7.7
  • 8.7
  • 8.7
  • 6.7
  • 8.7
Recent reviews
6.4 Good
Nov 17 2015
Bad Wipers, Underinflated Tires
Pros: car had a motor, ran well.
Cons: Wipers made driving in the rain nearly impossible. Had to pull over (in the rain) and fix them. Car pulled right. Pulled over and found all 4 tires underinflated, two with only 26 psi in them.
10.0 Excellent
Jun 12 2016
Great rental - no issues.
Pros: Quick service at the airport, but we flew in at a non-busy time.
Cons: Tgey always try to up sell yiu, but thats just business.
10.0 Excellent
Apr 4 2017
Personnel were pleasant and helpful
Pros: courtesy
7.6 Good
Aug 6 2017
Pickup time changed without notice
Pros: Great rental car
Cons: We really liked our rental car. The only problem we had was the pickup time being changed 2 hours later than what we were told. I called in after booking the rental to change our pickup time to 5 am and was told on the phone that the change was made and that the time would work. I decided to confirm the night before and was surprised when the automated system said our pickup time was 7 am. After talking to a representative they informed me that the location didn't open until 7 am so that was the earliest we could pick the car up. Aside from the obvious inconvenience, no one called or emailed me about the change, so if I hadn't confirmed we would have been waiting for two hours before we could pickup the car. Make sure to double check about pickup times.
10.0 Excellent
Aug 8 2017
Flexible drop off
Pros: We rent this car in Key west and have to drop off at the airport. And we saw a avis store near of our hotel. They let us drop off at this station. A perfect service. We booked the car very cheep by the website kayak.
Cons: You dont have to choose so many insurance. The insurance from avis is to expensive than from the alliance.
4.4 Okay
Nov 14 2017
Cons: The car, or any other car, was not available at the time of pickup.
Thrifty
Car rental reviews:
Good (6.9, 6 reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Thrifty
Locations in Key West
3495 S Roosevelt Blvd
+1 877 283 0898
  • 6.0
  • 7.7
  • 7.3
  • 7.0
  • 6.7
Recent reviews
6.0 Good
Sep 26 2016
Pros: Pick up was easy and fast.
Cons: Dropping off at Miami was difficult. Thrifty signs were not easy to see. The place looked like it was closed. Only one person working and he was very rude.
6.4 Good
Nov 22 2016
Cons: When we got to the EYW airport we were told the car size we had reserved was not available and the only option was a different car which was more expensive and we had to pay the difference. I think if they didn't have the car we had reserved months ago then they needed to eat the difference and not charge me. Had I not had a plane to catch in MIA I would have shopped for a different company.
10.0 Excellent
Apr 27 2017
Drop off gone great!
Pros: I ended up contracting with Dollar rental and there drop off option went smooth.
Cons: The first rep I spoke to was wonderful. However, I felt the second representative was rude on the phone when I called to go over details about dropping off vehicle after hours.
2.0 Mediocre
Apr 29 2017
Cons: Very unprofessional,rude and disrespectful. Last time using your services.
9.6 Excellent
Aug 18 2017
Quick Way to Key West
Pros: Great return staff. Helpful and efficient
7.6 Good
Oct 24 2017
False statements
Cons: I rented a convertible mustang or similar car for my 25th anniversary. I even spoke to them on the phone at the airport before unreserved it. When I arrived they did not have a convertible and said they had not had one in months. Had to take a Yukon.
Enterprise
enterprise
Car rental reviews:
Excellent (8.6, 6 reviews)
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Enterprise
Locations in Key West
2516 N Roosevelt Blvd
+1 305 292 0220
  • 8.0
  • 9.0
  • 9.0
  • 8.0
  • 9.0
Recent reviews
8.0 Excellent
Sep 11 2016
Cons: They employees take care customers very good
9.2 Excellent
Jan 8 2017
Easy Drop Off No Shuttle Back to Hotel
Pros: Easy Drop Off, Check, and Finalization of rental
Cons: No ride back to hotel, had to get cab.
Europcar
europcar
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Europcar
Locations in Key West
2516 North Roosevelt Blvd
National
national
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
National
Locations in Key West
2516 N Roosevelt Blvd
+1 844 868 8504
Sunnycars
sunnycars
Car rental locations in Key West:
1 location
Sunnycars
Locations in Key West
2516 North Roosevelt Boulevard
64 travelers who rented a car in Key West gave the car agency they used an average rating of 7.6

Car Rental Locations in Key West

Key West