Car Rental at New York Stewart Airport

Pros: All good

Cons: A little pricey

Only one complaint...

Cons: It was unclear that we had to go inside to drop off the car - most locations simply have a drop off right outside.

Great, No Fuss Thank You!

Pros: Ease of pickup and Return Experience.

Cons: Nothing

Great trip

Pros: Easy rental. We had to extend our rental and it was almost impossible thru the website, but the desk person was very helpful and we got it done without much pain!

Budget was great, I was a bit annoyed kayak though

Pros: Budget was great, I was a bit annoyed kayak though

Cons: When I reserve the car it gave me an option to add insurance. I thought I was adding the insurance through budget, but it turned out it was some third-party vendor. It was not obvious that this was the case. That kind of ticked me off after I found that out at the budget counter when they didn't have a record of me adding the insurance, even though I paid for it online. Then I found the email explaining the insurance was through some other company. That may have been stated on the website, but it really should have been a bit more obvious as I had no idea.