New Windsor car rentals

Search hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in New Windsor

New Windsor, NY
Dec 9 — Dec 16
Select
New Windsor, NY
Thu 12/9
Noon
Thu 12/16
Noon

Search hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in New Windsor

New Windsor car rental information

Pick-up locationNew Windsor
Car typesCompact, Compact SUV, Economy, Full-size, Full-size SUV, Intermediate, Intermediate SUV, Luxury, Pickup truck, Standard
Rental locations10
Airport locations9
Popular agenciesAvis, Enterprise, Budget, National

Cheap car rentals in New Windsor

Economy$38/day
Compact$38/day
Intermediate$37/day
Standard$41/day
Full-size$39/day
Full-size SUV$64/day
Luxury$91/day
Pickup truck$60/day
Compact SUV$55/day
Intermediate SUV$58/day
Best rates found by KAYAK users in the past hours.

New Windsor car rental reviews and directory

From $100/dayRated #1
Avis
Best rated
8.5 Excellent (31 reviews)
1 location in New Windsor
Avis
Locations in New Windsor
  • 8.6
  • 8.3
  • 8.5
  • 8.5
  • 8.3
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentNov 28 2021
Staff was wonderful and the car was reasonable
7.9 GoodSep 7 2021
Pretty long walk from counter to car when toting a few bags of luggage (>200 yards).
7.9 GoodAug 16 2021
Great car.
10.0 ExcellentAug 9 2021
The whole process was very easy.
5.9 OkayAug 8 2021
Car had a lot of damage. there was a safety malfunction error that kept displaying in dashboard. the brakes felt unsafe
10.0 ExcellentJul 20 2021
Incredibly easy pick up/drop off. Very helpful and friendly staff members at both pick up and drop off locations. Overall a great experience.
8.0 ExcellentJun 29 2021
Staff in New Windsor was extremely helpful, polite, and efficient!We had significant problems with the rental vehicle. The sliding doors on the minivan would not lock with the remote. The brakes on the Dodge Caravan were sketchy, and the ride from Eagle Lake down into Ticonderoga in upstate NY was about 7 miles down a steep highway. The rotors are extremely worn, and the minivan squealed all the way down the steep incline while the disc brakes bumped over the rotors. The minivan would not start at the end of the day while we were leaving Fort Ticonderoga. I called the 800 assistance number on the key ring, and THEY WERE NO HELP AT ALL. First they told me they would send someone out to jumpstart the vehicle, but I was worried that it would happen again. (We had a hard time starting it once before.) They suggested that after getting it started, I drive to the nearest Avis rental which was in Plattsburgh and 90 MILES AWAY!!! I told them I did not want to drive 180 miles round trip, so they suggested that I wait for road assistance to arrive and was told that roadside assistance would text me with a time. I waited 45 minutes with no text, and called them back. There was no answer. Fort Ticonderoga was closing, and I needed to leave as the gates were being locked! Roadside assistance did not pick up after that, and I was on hold for 45 minutes. I called the Burlington, VT Avis, and they told me to call Plattsburgh Avis which was extremely helpful. Plattsburgh Avis told me to call roadside assistance and request a two-way tow to exchange out the vehicle. I finally got back to the Avis roadside assistance, and the lady told me it would take 4-6 hours to do a two way tow. I told them that was unacceptable and the Fort was closing, and I needed to get the minivan out of the park. The lady said she would check with management and call me back. The park service was nice enough to stay and be prepared to reopen the gate for roadside Assistance WHICH NEVER CAME!!! The lady NEVER called me back, and I never got a text from anyone about roadside assistance. We finally got the van restarted ourselves. I called Avis roadside assistance again, and was on hold for 90 MINUTES just to tell them not to come, we got it started. That is the worst rental that I have ever had, and the Emergency Roadside Assistance number is a joke. I don’t know what I would have done if we had not gotten it started!!! I will look elsewhere for additional rentals. Tammy Curtis
10.0 ExcellentJun 28 2021
The staff at the Avis at New York Stewart Airport were really friendly, helpful, and efficient.
10.0 ExcellentJun 15 2021
Very accommodating, when calling to reschedule pick up due to cancelled flightIt’s a pretty long walk to ouch up car especially at night. But some employee was nice enough to get our car.
2.0 MediocreNov 23 2020
NothingFriendliness understanding and price
From $74/dayRated #2
Budget
8.5 Excellent (43 reviews)
1 location in New Windsor
Budget
Locations in New Windsor
  • 8.7
  • 8.7
  • 8.4
  • 8.1
  • 8.4
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentMay 21 2021
Quick easy
10.0 ExcellentFeb 7 2021
I love this companySoonroof
10.0 ExcellentJan 26 2020
Staff was friendly. Pick up and drop off was easy.Everything was easy. No complaints.
4.4 OkaySep 8 2019
finethey billed me for gas but i filled up the tank before dropping off the car
10.0 ExcellentAug 24 2019
Staff was efficient and friendly
8.4 ExcellentAug 10 2019
Staff at pick up was very quick and knowledgeable. Staff person at drop off was very slow and made me late for my appointment just checking car in at drop-off.More staff help at drop off location. Same person at counter doing both check in and check out.
10.0 ExcellentJul 10 2019
Easy pick up and return
8.4 ExcellentApr 19 2019
We got different information about leaving our car at their parking lot when my husband and I called separately. We also got conflicting information about the time to return the rental. In the end it all worked out, but it just seemed concerning that we'd get a different answer when we each called
10.0 ExcellentAug 30 2018
Great!Very easy to get a car. It busy. Friendly people.Nothing really
2.0 MediocreMay 7 2018
NothingConfusing web site caused me to reserve a car at the wrong location. This error tripled my rental costs.
Show more reviews
From $48/dayRated #3
Hertz
Cheapest deal
9.1 Excellent (12 reviews)
1 location in New Windsor
Hertz
Locations in New Windsor
  • 9.3
  • 9.1
  • 9.3
  • 9.3
  • 8.6
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentOct 6 2017
Easiest car rental everConvenient, easy, small airport, ease of return and friendly staff and no hidden costs.
9.2 ExcellentSep 12 2017
Staff was very helpful, friendly and efficientThe colour of the car (white)
From $78/dayRated #4
Enterprise
Most popular
8.7 Excellent (11 reviews)
2 locations in New Windsor
Enterprise
Locations in New Windsor
  • 7.6
  • 9.2
  • 8.7
  • 8.9
  • 8.1
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentSep 15 2021
Megan was great
7.9 GoodAug 12 2021
I did like the service and the smile from everyone. The only thing I didn't like was how dirty the vehicle was. This was the first time ever that I got a dirty rental car. Thanks
8.0 ExcellentMay 27 2021
Yes yesBetter cleaning
10.0 ExcellentJul 28 2020
YesAll was well
8.4 ExcellentDec 31 2018
Gave me a free "upgrade" to an SUV, though I reserved and wanted a smaller car, which wasn't available.
Rated #5
National
6 Good (2 reviews)
1 location in New Windsor
National
Locations in New Windsor
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentSep 9 2016
Above my expectationsUpgraded my car, a fabulous ride, friendly and price agreed upon.There isn't anything I can think of.
Rated #6
Alamo
1.9 Horrible (5 reviews)
1 location in New Windsor
Alamo
Locations in New Windsor
  • 3.1
  • 2.3
  • 1.9
  • 3.1
  • 2.3
Recent reviews
1.9 HorribleAug 10 2021
Spent about 6 hours in total talking with customer service and a lot of frustration and anger residues are still with me.
2.0 MediocreMay 9 2021
the drop offnot charging me more at counter after i booked a $80 1 day rental and then charged $140 at counter when picking up car.
2.0 MediocreDec 15 2020
Hotwire is listing Alamo at SWF for car rentals. I booked on hotwire one month in advance for a 1-way rental from NY to Fla. I get to SWF to find out they are only open when they have a reservation from an arriving flight. UGH! There is no one there and when you call Alamo 800 #, they say, oh yes, sure they are open, have airport security page them as they must be just away from the desk momentarily. Clueless. I call the number listed on the notice pasted at the desk. They tell me to get to the Enterprise location 5 miles away, they will honor the reservation. I wait 30mins and pay $12 for a cab to Enterprise at 63 Route 17K in Newburgh, only to be told they will honor the reservation, but not the price. Two very unfriendly, very unhelpful men could not have cared less about my predicament. UGH!! I call Alamo 800# again and they are sorry but since covid has effectively closed the airport, they are not offering what they call local rentals to anyone not arriving via plane. When I tell her hotwire/priceline/kayak are still offering rentals at SWF, she says she is sorry, but cannot control what they do. I learned my lesson NEVER RENT from ALAMO or ENTERPRISE.I learned my lesson NEVER RENT from ALAMO or ENTERPRISE.
2.0 MediocreDec 6 2020
Nothing .The proper information on your website would be nice. The location i was allowed to book at online did not even have anyone working the location .drove all the way to the pick up location to and empty service desk. called to find out that they do not service customers who are not fly ins , which should have been disclosed because I then had to find another service that cost me over $300 dollars more for my needs and an additional $200 charge deposit on top of it.I could have been stranded .do better.
2.0 MediocreDec 5 2020
I wa not able to pick up the car! Drove to the airport to get the car and there was so no one there! There was a small sign that redirected me to an enterprise in town. When I got there they tried adding $300 to my fee. Left without my car. Never using Alamo or enterprise again.
Easirent
1 location in New Windsor
Easirent
Locations in New Windsor
Recent reviews
Empire Rent A Car
1 location in New Windsor
Empire Rent A Car
Locations in New Windsor
Recent reviews
Sunnycars
1 location in New Windsor
Sunnycars
Locations in New Windsor
Recent reviews
104 travelers who rented a car in New Windsor gave the car agency they used an average rating of 8.2

Car rental locations in or near New Windsor

Good to know

Most popular agency

Enterprise

Most popular car type

Compact

Average price

$92/day

Good deal

$73/day

When to book a rental car in New Windsor

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Top tips for renting a car in New Windsor

  • 25% of our users found rental cars in New Windsor for $73 or less
  • Book your rental car in New Windsor at least 4 weeks before your trip in order to get a below-average price
  • Off-airport rental car locations in New Windsor are around 72% more expensive than airport locations on average
  • Compact rental cars in New Windsor are around 55% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about renting a car in New Windsor