Car rental at Islip Long Island Airport

Car rental at Islip Long Island Airport

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for airport car rental deals at Islip Long Island Airport (ISP)

Islip, NY - Long Island
Jan 27 — Feb 3
Same drop-off
Islip, NY - Long Island
Thu 1/27
Noon
Thu 2/3
Noon

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for airport car rental deals at Islip Long Island Airport (ISP)

Cheap car rentals in Islip Long Island Airport

Economy$55/day
Compact$56/day
Intermediate$57/day
Standard$60/day
Full-size$63/day
Minivan$90/day
Full-size SUV$72/day
Luxury$67/day
Intermediate SUV$55/day
Standard SUV$60/day
Best rates found by KAYAK users in the past hours.

Islip Long Island Airport car rental reviews and directory

Rated #1
Budget
Best rated
8.7 Excellent (34 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Budget
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 8.9
  • 8.9
  • 8.6
  • 8.8
  • 8.3
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentJan 8 2022
Excellent service vehicle was perfect both pickup and drop off were well done the staff was very helpful
3.9 MediocreAug 15 2021
Throughout the entire rental the vehicle displayed warning messages for oil levels and service, along with emergency lights on the front display. At drop off the attendant behind the counter was made aware of these issues but was very uninterested and dismissive.
10.0 ExcellentJun 18 2021
Absolutely! Great staff! Drop off was very easy.Nothing!
10.0 ExcellentMar 7 2021
Everyone was happy here
2.0 MediocreSep 27 2020
The desk was closed when I arrived. All plans were messed up.
10.0 ExcellentAug 20 2020
The staff was very friendly.
10.0 ExcellentAug 5 2019
Car was well equipped and clean. Value was goodNothing. Everything exceeded expectations.
7.6 GoodSep 11 2018
Drop off was fine at MacArthur AirportOffice was easy to find.Everything was fine at drop off.
9.6 ExcellentDec 28 2017
Very easy to getSimple pick up and drop off. No problem at all. Friendly staff.I wanted to get the car for 2 more days but had to keep that same price instead of getting the lower price now offered. they told me to return the car and go on line and rent another one from therm. We filled the gas across the street and when we returned We were told we had to pay $16.00. We fought it.
10.0 ExcellentNov 7 2017
everything so easy
Rated #2
Enterprise
9.4 Excellent (26 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Enterprise
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 9.4
  • 9.1
  • 9.3
  • 9.6
  • 9.3
Recent reviews
8.0 ExcellentApr 15 2017
They almost got it right...Customer service.They don't offer EZpass on cars rented to New York state residents. It makes zero sense considering we have bridges & tolls.
10.0 ExcellentMar 15 2017
ramgreat truck
8.8 ExcellentMar 10 2017
Easy ReturnEasy to return vehicle, good signs.There was no attendant so we had to go into terminal. It's a small airport and it wasn't difficult to du that. Just would have been faster with an attendant on hand.
6.4 GoodFeb 25 2017
I got a car.The staff was very friendly, explained the conditions thoroughly and treated me well. They offered to switch me into a larger car if I were to come back the next day which was appreciated. The car was clean and it was easy to find.The car I got was one size smaller then what I had reserved, which is significant since I'm pretty tall. They offered to switch me into a larger car if I came back the next day, but since I was only using the car for two days it was not worth it. I gave one day's notice, which I'm sure impacted the selection, but a larger car should not have been advertised if that were the situation.
10.0 ExcellentJan 30 2017
courteous helpful staff. price was right.what's not to like?
6.0 GoodDec 11 2016
ExspensiveI felt it was too exspensivePrice
10.0 ExcellentDec 2 2016
Great Customer ServiceEnterprise was awesome. They were professional, courteous, and efficient.
10.0 ExcellentNov 28 2016
Great rate great vehicle great serviceI had a family emergency so I was 12 hours late picking up the car and needed to extend the rental from 4 -7 days. They accommodated both requests without increasing the rate. LOVED the Jeep renegade!Nothing
8.8 ExcellentOct 10 2016
Great Customer ServiceGood service on pick-up/drop-off. I prepaid for a whole tank of gas and only used a 1/4 tank. Upon return, the person checking in credited my total amount for a 1/2 tank of gas. That is great customer service and will keep me coming back.The car (nisan versa note) driver's seat was not that comfortable. I had difficulty adjusting the back of the seat.
Rated #3
National
9.1 Excellent (16 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
National
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 9.2
  • 9.1
  • 9.1
  • 9.1
  • 9
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentNov 22 2021
Great quick service. Car clean easy pickup and drop off.
10.0 ExcellentAug 11 2021
The process was seamless. The guest services personnel were so friendly and efficient . Renting in a small airport is a dream come true.
10.0 ExcellentApr 1 2021
The vehicle was fairly priced, clean and ran well. Pick up and drop off was hassle free.I don't have any complaints.
10.0 ExcellentJul 1 2019
Staff was very friendly and helpful
10.0 ExcellentJan 17 2017
Everyone at pick up and drop off was very nice and helpful. It was actually a very pleasant experience. The girls were all wonderful
10.0 ExcellentNov 12 2016
Pleasant experienceEverything
8.0 ExcellentOct 2 2016
Checking out and checking in were very efficient.Charges included a lot of extra fees which had not been mentioned.
Rated #4
Hertz
8.2 Excellent (2 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Hertz
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 8
  • 9
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
Recent reviews
8.4 ExcellentNov 16 2018
nice car. nice person at the counter. easy pick up.
Show more reviews
Rated #5
Thrifty
7.9 Good (21 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Thrifty
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 8.1
  • 8
  • 8
  • 7.9
  • 7.7
Recent reviews
5.2 OkayJun 19 2020
the drop off location was closed for several weeks and I only discovered this by reading a sign on the door.
10.0 ExcellentJan 5 2020
staff was very helpful at pick up and drop off was fast and easy
10.0 ExcellentJan 2 2020
staff was great at pick up and drop offnope
10.0 ExcellentDec 19 2019
The vehicle was nicer then I expected. It was very comfortable and drove great!The tires were really bald luckily I didn’t drive through any bad weather.
7.2 GoodNov 4 2019
Everything was good
10.0 ExcellentAug 30 2018
Easy drop off.
9.2 ExcellentAug 28 2018
Car was to small otherwise everything was good
2.0 MediocreJan 1 2018
NightmareI was told after a month early reservation and early online check in that I was on the “do not rent to list”. This is on Christmas Day as I’m ready to leave for a family trip to NC. There was nobody available by phone to rectify this by phone. I am disgusted.
10.0 ExcellentSep 11 2017
Courteousness. Willing to work with us due to travel circumstances associated with hurricane Irma. One less worry for us. Thank you
10.0 ExcellentAug 18 2017
Value for money, I am glad I got a good deal. Hope I get more better deals as I am frequent flyer to NY.
Rated #6
Avis
7.6 Good (20 reviews)
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Avis
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
  • 7.7
  • 7.9
  • 7.5
  • 8.1
  • 7.1
Recent reviews
2.0 MediocreDec 6 2021
I changed 3 cars on this trip. First car tire pressure was low Second car was extremely dirty Third car the check engine light came on
1.9 HorribleSep 8 2021
These clowns didn’t have any cars when I got to the airport. Had to use Uber which was a TOTAL inconvenience. I’ll never use Avis again.
10.0 ExcellentAug 21 2021
It was an easy process to pick up my car and return my car. My customer service person at islip Macarthur airport was very friendly and courteous. I think her name was Sissy!
1.9 HorribleJul 26 2021
They were very friendly at pick up, and it was very easy and straight forward. Or so it seemed. But when I returned the car there were huge unexpected and hidden additional charges that made the cost of the rental untenable and felt like an abuse of consumer protection as it was three times what I was quoted as the expected cost.
10.0 ExcellentAug 21 2020
Atención 100%
4.8 OkayNov 10 2019
The car was dirty. The inside windows hadn't been washed in a long long time.
2.0 MediocreAug 20 2019
no..drove to picknit up to be told no more cars left.Could of let me know before I drove a hour that there was no cars left..
10.0 ExcellentJan 6 2019
Best wayEasy drop off at jfkFinding open gas station price to pay if not back fillef
10.0 ExcellentAug 3 2017
Cheap
10.0 ExcellentMar 22 2017
Great customer serviceThe man who helped me at ISP airport was amazing - he made it quick with no headache.
Easirent
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Easirent
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
Recent reviews
Empire Rent A Car
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Empire Rent A Car
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
Recent reviews
Sunnycars
1 location in Islip Long Island Airport
Sunnycars
Locations in Islip Long Island Airport
Recent reviews
119 travelers who rented a car in Islip Long Island Airport gave the car agency they used an average rating of 8.6

Car rental locations at Islip Long Island Airport

Good to know

Most popular agency

Thrifty

Most popular car type

Mini

Average price

$73/day

Good deal

$55/day

Top tips for renting a car at Islip Long Island Airport

  • While this airport does have several different transportation options to get you from the airport to the center of town, each of them has its drawbacks. Buses can take quite a bit of time to make the trip plus you have to worry about what you are going to do with all your luggage while traveling on a bus. Taxis, shuttles, and town cars are all an option, but they can be a rather pricey trip. That is why car rental at Islip Long Island Airport (ISP) is such a great option because it gives you convenience and a cost-effective trip.
  • Car rental at Islip Long Island Airport is very easy because all the rental car companies have their customer service counters right inside the terminal building near the baggage claim area. Once you have proceeded to the rental car company's counter and picked up your keys and your contract you can just step outside the terminal building to hop on the shuttle bus to take you to your rental car company. The rental car companies are only a short distance from the terminal building and the ride to the rental car companies takes only about 2min. There are shuttle buses that make stops at the terminal buildings roughly every 5min during the day.
  • When you are ready to return your car rental at Islip Long Island Airport all you need to do is take the car back to the rental car company where you pick it up, note your mileage and your gas level, and then lock the car and put the contract and the keys in the dropbox that you will find in the returns area for the rental car company. Once you've done that you can board the same shuttle that brought you to the rental car lot to take you back to the terminal building.
  • Even though this is a smaller airport it is a popular one and as such, there are going to be busier times to try to get an Islip Long Island Airport car rental. This is going to be true on afternoons and especially on Friday afternoons when people are traveling here for a weekend trip. Because of that and because smaller airports and have smaller rental fleets, it is always best that you book a reservation at one of the rental car companies before making your trip here to make sure the vehicle is waiting for you upon your arrival.
  • 25% of our users found rental cars at Islip Long Island Airport for $62 or less
  • Book your rental car at Islip Long Island Airport at least 1 day before your trip in order to get a below-average price

FAQs about renting a car at Islip Long Island Airport