Monticello car rentals

Compare hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Monticello, New York

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Save up to 39%Compare multiple travel sites with one search.

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by car type, brand and more. Instantly customise your results.

Book with flexibilityUse our "free cancellation" filter for maximum flexibility at no extra cost.

Cheap car rentals in Monticello

Discover the best prices and deals for you by selecting your travel dates.
Choose your dates
Economy car
Economy
Compact car
Compact
Intermediate car
Intermediate
Standard car
Standard
Full-size car
Full-size
Luxury car
Luxury
Minivan car
Minivan
Passenger van car
Passenger van
Commercial car
Commercial
Pickup truck car
Pickup truck

KAYAK’s top tips for renting a car in Monticello

  • Utilizing Monticello car rentals offers several advantages. It provides flexibility and convenience, allowing you to explore the region at your own pace without being tied to public transportation schedules. With a car, you can easily reach attractions like the Monticello Raceway, Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, and Catskill State Park, which might be less accessible by other means. This autonomy to visit famous and off-the-beaten-path destinations makes Car rentals in Monticello a preferable option for maximizing your experience in and around Monticello.
  • When you arrive at Monticello, you'll have the option of landing at John F. Kennedy Intl (JFK), Newark Airport (EWR), or LaGuardia Airport (LGA). Renting a car might be a good idea to facilitate your exploration of the city. The car rental process varies at each airport: At JFK, you'll find rental car counters and courtesy phones conveniently located on the Arrivals Level near the baggage carousels. You can use the AirTrain system to reach the Federal Circle Station, where rental cars are available. For EWR, taking the Newark Air Train to Station P3 is the way to access the car rental center. This station is well-connected and can be reached by following clear signs and escalators. If you touch down at LGA's Terminal A, you can catch a company shuttle from the Rental Car Shuttle Transfer Point to the rental center.
  • Driving in Monticello follows a calm and relaxed style, reflecting the town's peaceful atmosphere. Most drivers respect traffic rules and display courteous behavior. While the area doesn't have many bicycles or heavy truck traffic, occasional pedestrians may be seen jaywalking. Common vehicles include sedans and SUVs; some residents might drive trucks or minivans. The city maintains a considerate driving environment or moving car rentals in Monticello, emphasizing safety and adherence to traffic regulations.
  • Driving car rentals in Monticello can be challenging due to rush hour traffic. Rush hour in this city occurs during weekday mornings (around 7:30 am to 9 am) and afternoons (around 4:30 pm to 6 pm). Traffic can be heavier on key roads like State Route 17B and Broadway during these times. While Monticello doesn't experience extreme traffic congestion, these periods might see a slight increase in vehicles due to commuters. Winters might present more challenging driving conditions due to snow and ice, requiring caution on roads like State Route 17B and Forestburgh Road.
  • 25% of our users found rental cars in Monticello for $54 or less
  • Book your rental car in Monticello at least 1 day before your trip in order to get a below-average price
  • Compact rental cars in Monticello are around 35% cheaper than other car types, on average
See more tips

FAQs about renting a car in Monticello

  • How much does it cost to rent a car in Monticello?

    On average a rental car in Monticello costs $60 per day. But prices differ between operators and you can save money through a price comparison of car rental deals from different agencies. The cheapest price for a car rental in Monticello found in the last 2 weeks is $51.

  • How much is gas price in Monticello?

    The average gas price in Monticello is $3.40 per gallon over the past 30 days. Filling up a gas tank costs between $41 and $54, depending on the car size.

  • What is the most popular rental car in Monticello?

    Compact (Ford Focus or similar) is the most frequently booked rental car type in Monticello.

  • Which car rental companies are at John F Kennedy Intl airport (JFK)?

    Car rental companies onsite at John F Kennedy Intl airport include Payless, Yesaway, Empire Rent A Car, Routes Car & Truck Rentals, Dollar, Thrifty, Enterprise Rent-A-Car and Avis.

  • Which car rental companies are at Newark airport (EWR)?

    Car rental companies onsite at Newark airport include Fox, Payless, Rent-A-Wreck, Kyte, Hertz, Alamo and Budget.

  • Which car rental companies are at LaGuardia airport (LGA)?

    Car rental companies onsite at LaGuardia airport include Payless, Yesaway, Empire Rent A Car, Dollar and Thrifty.

  • Which car rental companies will pick you up at John F Kennedy Intl airport (JFK)?

    Car rental companies that offer shuttle or pick-up services from John F Kennedy Intl airport to off-airport locations include Payless, Dollar, Thrifty, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, and Avis.

  • Which car rental companies will pick you up at Newark airport (EWR)?

    Car rental companies that offer shuttle or pick-up services from Newark airport to off-airport locations include Payless, Hertz, Alamo, and Budget.

  • Which car rental companies will pick you up at LaGuardia airport (LGA)?

    Car rental companies that offer shuttle or pick-up services from LaGuardia airport to off-airport locations include Payless, Dollar, Thrifty, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, and Avis.

  • How can I find car rentals near me in Monticello?

    Take a look at our extensive car rental location map to find the best rental cars near you.

  • How much does a Compact car rental cost in Monticello?

    A Compact car rental in Monticello costs $46 per day, on average.

  • How much does a Standard car rental cost in Monticello?

    A Standard car rental in Monticello costs $51 per day, on average.

  • How much does a Premium car rental cost in Monticello?

    A Premium car rental in Monticello costs $78 per day, on average.

  • How much does it cost to rent a car for a week in Monticello?

    On average a rental car in Monticello costs $418 per week ($60 per day).

  • How much does it cost to rent a car long term for a month in Monticello?

    On average a rental car in Monticello costs $1,791 per month ($60 per day).

  • Should I get insurance when renting a car in Monticello?

    Most car rental providers in Monticello offer insurance but the level of protection can differ substantially. If you're unsure whether to get extra protection for your car rental in Monticello, check out KAYAK's car rental insurance guide.

  • How many car agencies are operating in Monticello?

    KAYAK has deals for you to compare from 1 car rental agencies in Monticello.

  • What do I need to know before booking a car rental in Monticello?

    Finding the right price, understanding the add-ons and staying up to date with policy changes can be a challenge. That’s why KAYAK has produced the ultimate guide to renting a car to help you cut though the jargon and make the right choice for your rental car. Find tips and insights for how to book your rental, what car rental insurance you’ll need, how to deal with a car rental agency and what extra fees to expect (and avoid!).

  • Why should I use KAYAK to rent a car in Monticello?

    KAYAK searches thousands of car rental agencies to provide you with offers from all car rental agencies operating in Monticello so that you can compare car rental rates, reviews and pick-up and drop-off locations to find the best deal for you.

  • What type of car is recommended for driving in Monticello?

    A comfortable and versatile midsize SUV is recommended when looking for car rentals in Monticello. An SUV provides ample space for passengers and luggage, making it suitable for exploring the area's attractions and outdoor destinations. With potentially varying weather conditions, the SUV's higher clearance and all-wheel-drive capabilities can enhance stability and safety, particularly during winter. This type of vehicle balances city maneuverability and the ability to handle different terrains, making it an ideal choice for a well-rounded driving experience in Monticello.

  • What's the speed limit in Monticello?

    In Monticello, the general speed limit on most local roads is 30 mph, which is expected within residential and commercial areas. However, it's essential to be aware of any posted signs indicating specific speed limits, as they might vary based on your road type. Some areas might have lower speed limits, particularly near schools or densely populated zones. Also, watch out for speed cameras, which could be placed in areas prone to speeding violations. Adhering to posted limits ensures safety and helps you avoid potential fines.

  • Where are the best places to park in Monticello?

    Parking is more straightforward in Monticello due to its small-town nature and less congested streets. When driving car rentals in Monticello, convenient parking options are available downtown, including street parking and public lots near popular attractions like the Monticello Raceway and local eateries. Street parking is often metered and requires payment during specific hours. Public lots generally offer hourly or daily rates ranging from $1 to $5. It's advisable to carry small denominations for meters. Be mindful of parking regulations to avoid fines.

See more FAQs

Monticello car rental reviews and directory 
All ratings and reviews are collected from KAYAK users with a verified car rental booking. Learn how KAYAK collects reviews.

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

8.0

Very good

Read 1 review
Best rated

Cleanliness

7.0

Comfort

8.0

Pick-up/Drop-off

8.0

Value for money

8.0

4 locations in Monticello

Show locations

Locations in Monticello

102 Cimarron Rd

+1 845 791 9938

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00
Saturday09:00 - 12:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00

265 Route 211 E

+1 845 648 2119

Monday07:30 - 17:30
Tuesday07:30 - 17:30
Wednesday07:30 - 17:30
Thursday07:30 - 17:30
Friday07:30 - 17:30
Saturday09:00 - 12:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00

500 Routes 6 And 209

+1 570 409 1046

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00
Saturday09:00 - 12:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00

911 Pennsylvania Ave

+1 570 409 1046

Opening times not available

Filters

Reviews

10.0 Wonderful

Anonymous, Mar 2021

KAYAK

Pros:

Very good staff

Cons:

Car had cigarette odor and was a bit pricey

1 out of 1

Budget

6.4

Okay

Cheapest deal
Most popular

One location in Monticello

Show locations

Locations in Monticello

42 East Main Street, Suite 46

+1 845 754 2254

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00
Saturday08:00 - 17:00

Filters

No reviews available

Payless

6.9

Okay

One location in Monticello

Show locations

Locations in Monticello

42 E Main St. Ste 46

+1 845 856 0800

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00
Saturday08:00 - 17:00

Filters

No reviews available

NextCar

5.0

Fair

One location in Monticello

Show locations

Locations in Monticello

42-46 East Main Street

+1 845 856 2277

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00

Filters

No reviews available

Hertz

No score available yet

3 locations in Monticello

Show locations

Locations in Monticello

22 County Rd 78

+1 845 343 9947

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00

22 County Road 78

+1 845 343 9947

Monday08:00 - 17:00
Tuesday08:00 - 17:00
Wednesday08:00 - 17:00
Thursday08:00 - 17:00
Friday08:00 - 17:00

57 County Road 183a

+1 845 583 3080

Monday09:00 - 12:00
Tuesday09:00 - 12:00
Wednesday09:00 - 12:00
Thursday09:00 - 12:00
Friday09:00 - 12:00

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

4.0 Mediocre

Anonymous, Sep 2020

KAYAK

Pros:

Long, long lines, 1 person at desk, no one answers the phone for 2.5 hours. I was 10 minutes late because of traffic/surgery got charged a full day.

Cons:

ANSWER THE PHONE!! Have more than 1 person at desk. Don't fall for the low price BS. Rent where you can return after 5pm.

2.0 Poor

JPC, Apr 2020

KAYAK

Cons:

I booked online and paid. When I arrived at the pick-up location there was a sign in the door saying they were closed for the day. This put me in a bind because I had a schedule to keep.

2.0 Poor

Anonymous, Aug 2023

Compact

KAYAK
Clean, good-sized car, but no GPS! If you don’t have a US phone with its own wifi and Google maps they have nothing for you to help you find your way. Very unhelpful staff in Middletown. When I was trying to find solutions for my almost 300 mile trip their only suggestion was to cancel my contract and leave me hanging. What are your options for people without US cell phones??

6.0 Okay

Anonymous, Jul 2023

Compact

KAYAK
It was hard to get ahold of anyone at the counter. The car was not clean and ready when we got there. The price was good for the weekly rate.

1.9 Poor

Anonymous, Aug 2021

KAYAK
Had to cancel reservation. There was No-one at the hertz office only one employee washing a vehicle. I waited half an hour and was not taken care.

1 out of 2

2043 travelers who rented a car in Monticello gave the car agency they used an average rating of 6.0

Car rental locations in or near Monticello

Good to know

Most popular agency

Budget

Most popular car type

Compact

Average price

$60/day

Good deal

$54/day

When to book a rental car in Monticello

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Monticello car rental information

Pick-up locationMonticello
Car types
Rental locations1
Airport locations0

Not what you’re looking for? Find thousands of other hotels, flights, car rentals and package deals with KAYAK.