Fisher Island car rentals

Search hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Fisher Island

Fisher Island, FL
Oct 27 — Nov 3
Same drop-off
Fisher Island, FL
Wed 10/27
Noon
Wed 11/3
Noon

Search hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Fisher Island

Fisher Island car rental reviews and directory

From $31/dayRated #1
Hertz
Best rated
Most popular
6.9 Good (53 reviews)
1 location in Fisher Island
Hertz
Locations in Fisher Island
  • 7.2
  • 7.2
  • 6.7
  • 6.1
  • 7.2
Recent reviews
2.4 MediocreNov 13 2019
Hertz overbooked its reservations. On the morning of pickup, the staff told us there were no cars available for the 6 people waiting with confirmed reservations. Took them about 2 hours to scramble to find other cars for us. It wasn't the fault of the staff at the location, but of Hertz Corporate overbooking their vehicles.
10.0 ExcellentAug 14 2019
Prompt quick and reliable service
9.6 ExcellentAug 13 2019
I think the car rental place closing at 5 on Monday is ridiculous. Everything else was great.
2.0 MediocreJun 11 2019
My debit card was alittle damaged from the back that it wouldn’t swipe they didn’t NOT want to Type in my information and basically we’re no help. I had to walk up and down south beach with my bags looking for another car rental place.
2.0 MediocreMay 18 2019
NothingWell at least you had to give me the possibility to rent the car.
8.0 ExcellentApr 9 2019
Easy process to pickup and drop-off.I was given a midsize car instead of the full-size I had reserved.
7.6 GoodFeb 13 2019
LocationPick up
10.0 ExcellentJan 29 2019
The garage the rentals are kept in was a little confusing to enter especially when you had to punch for a ticket. Otherwise it as great!
2.0 MediocreSep 24 2018
Rip offObnoxious company Lied about hours of location Impossible to get in contact with Overcharge at desk for upgrade
3.2 MediocreMay 8 2018
I was told at the Orlando airport counter that I could drop off the car at 530 Collins Ave as long as it was by the time I recorded my pick up which was 9:40. I asked him what time they closed and he said I was ok as long as I dropped it by that time. I got to the location, couldn’t even find where to park and notice it looked like it was closed. I was in the car so I asked someone on the sidewalk if they could tell what the sign said on the door. The hours where until 6:00 ad of course I was there to return it at 6:30. Way before I even had to! I tried calling, couldn’t get anyone. Waited several minutes on an alley smack in the middle of South Beach. My sister checked google for other locations while I was on my phone waiting to speak to someone. Found out I could go to 247 - 20 St at the beach and they were open until 8:30. Got there, difficult to identify, finally speaking to someone on a screen. Left car and key and she asked me if I wanted a printed copy of receipt or email. I said to email, she verdes the correct one and said the confirmation was on its way. This was two days ago and so far nothing received! Very dissatisfied with Hertz!!!
From $48/dayRated #2
Sixt
9 Excellent (7 reviews)
1 location in Fisher Island
Sixt
Locations in Fisher Island
  • 9.7
  • 9.1
  • 8.8
  • 8.8
  • 8.8
Recent reviews
10.0 ExcellentApr 9 2021
Staff was very helpful and detailedEverything was perfect.
5.2 OkayJun 26 2020
Drop off was easy and a relief. Vehicle was clean.I ordered a luxury, they had none. I paid for a Mercedes SUV Luxury vehicle. I was on hold for over 90 minutes (screen shot of call) when I tried to complain. I received a Jeep Grand Cherokee. And 25 dollars off my bill. They wanted to refund my debit card I paid with 2 weeks prior to my reservation. Then charge it to a major credit card. I asked why charged and refunded. They then Claimed I didn't read terms and conditions where it explains everything. I was not the only client they did this to while i was there. I wasn't the only one Sixt did this to that day. They didn't have someone elses luxury vehicle who had prepaid and scheduled to be picked up and already paid for. They bate you for what you want online then switch with shitty model and take off a very small inconvenience "sorry" while charging you for tolls and extra insurances. Scam will not use sixt again. Ever.
From $22/dayRated #3
Budget
Cheapest deal
7 Good (23 reviews)
1 location in Fisher Island
Budget
Locations in Fisher Island
  • 7
  • 7
  • 6.9
  • 7.2
  • 6.8
Recent reviews
6.0 GoodDec 24 2019
The woman at the pick up counter was wonderful and did a great job. The car itself was not clean inside and there were even stains on the seats.
2.0 MediocreAug 6 2019
Kayak Allowed me to make a reservation but when I arrived budget did not have any cars available to rent so why doesn’t KAYAK allow a reservation to be made if the facility has no cars available. This happens over and over again with other car rental agencies booked via KAYAK
3.2 MediocreApr 8 2018
Fuel guageFile guage didn’t work. Hard to refuel.
10.0 ExcellentFeb 16 2018
ServiceN/A
2.8 MediocreOct 28 2017
NothingThey took out extra money because of their mistake and after they did not return the full amount. I will never again take the car in Budget. In the Budget - budgetary service ...
2.0 MediocreApr 17 2017
No car available on contracted date. Had to rent a car at hotel for muNo car! Owner apologetic but did not help our situation.
2.0 MediocreMar 6 2017
Bad drop offDrop off was a disaster as it was poorly labeled
10.0 ExcellentDec 19 2015
Great peopleSuper helpful and courteous...but Miami is a pretty nice and friendly place anyway. Much better than our experience in other Florida cities...namely Orlando. Car was not great...
10.0 ExcellentDec 11 2015
Quick, easy, great valueUnder $20/day for a full size Chevy Impala? That's a great deal. I just needed it for the day. Very easy and accessible location. Very friendly agent. All around a great experience.1- The gas tank was full, and I returned it with half a tank. Usually rental companies charge a small premium for the gas if you don't bring the car back with as much gas as it had it the tank when you got it, but I war HORRIFIED to learn that the cost of buying the gas through Budget$10/gallon gas through Budget was $10/gallon!!!!! So I had to take the car back out of the structure, and gas up, which ordinarily isn't a problem. However, I was visiting Miami during Art Basel, and traffic was the worst I've ever experienced in my live (I'm from LA). So that was a shame that I couldn't take advantage of the convenience factor of returning the car half full without paying $10/gallon for gas. 2- During the booking process, Kayak offered me insurance on the rental. It mentioned that the insurance was being bought through Alianz, the 3rd party insurance provider, but I presumed I would pay for this at the rental counter. In fact the insurance was pre-paid, and while it was cheaper than Budget's insurance at the counter, I wish I'd have had the option to buy this insurance at the counter.
8.0 ExcellentNov 3 2015
The car was newThe line for take the car was big
From $37/dayRated #4
Enterprise
5.8 Okay (11 reviews)
2 locations in Fisher Island
Enterprise
Locations in Fisher Island
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 5.4
Recent reviews
2.0 MediocreOct 13 2020
Nothing. They didn’t have any cars for us to take and left us stranded.Everything. They didn’t have any cars for us to take and left us stranded. The girl was rude and didn’t communicate well as to how she was trying to fix the problem. We ended up leaving the location and going with a rental car down the street.
2.0 MediocreOct 13 2020
Nothing.Lady at the desk was incredibly rude and unhelpful. Reserved a convertible. Not only did they not have a convertible, but they actually didn’t have ANY cars available at the time we reserved. And we had a tour booked that we were trying to make. After an hour they told us that they’d located a car but that it was getting an oil change and therefore may take another hour. So we canceled, ubered to Budget, and got a car on the spot.
2.0 MediocreApr 25 2019
I had booked the car for 9.00am. at 11.00 was not yet available, I had to cancel and cancel everything.
2.0 MediocreDec 30 2018
I’ve come to rent agency, and there are no any cars available.
2.0 MediocreDec 29 2018
Aweful. Showed up for our reservation and they didn’t have a carThis was an awful experience. Showed up with a reservation, and after waiting in an empty office for 20 min, someone finally showed up and said they were completely backed up and didn’t have any cars available whatsoever. 13 groups of people were waiting ahead of me who had been there for hours waiting. We had a 2 day car rental, and they said they couldn’t guarantee a car by tomorrow. What’s the point of a reservation if they don’t give you a car? They shouldn’t have given us a reservation if they didn’t have cars available because we could have at least rented from another company. We had to lyft the rest of the weekend, which was a pain because we have newborns and car seats.
9.2 ExcellentJan 29 2017
The service and the car was very nice.I don't like the fact that when I made a reservation I didn't see the final price. When I gave the car back it was about 40 dollars more because of the tax and additional surcharge. I do not understand why the system can't show me the final price with taxes and etc when I book? Because of this I won't book the car here again as I will never know the final price.
Rated #5
Payless
3 Mediocre (5 reviews)
1 location in Fisher Island
Payless
Locations in Fisher Island
  • 2
  • 3.2
  • 2.8
  • 3.6
  • 3.6
Recent reviews
2.0 MediocreJul 21 2020
Booked a reservation and location was closed, unable to pick up a vehicle and unable to obtain refund via car rental company or the third party site for the resevation.
7.2 GoodJul 8 2019
Manager at the desk was excellent!!!! Super fast and friendlyCar was not cleaned between rentals and filled will paper and packing supplies
2.0 MediocreFeb 11 2019
You made a reservation for a company that doesn’t work out of that location anymore so when I went to get the car they did not accept the reservation so I had to make a walk-in reservation with them at twice the rate because I didn’t have a choice.
2.0 MediocreJan 31 2019
I was given a reservation for a car rental from a location and company that was no longer in business was there. I was given a reservation for a car in Payless rental car but when I went to the location it was a Budget rental car and they said they do not accept reservations from Payless.
2.0 MediocreJan 17 2019
they did not have system so could not rent the car!
ACO Rent A Car
1 location in Fisher Island
ACO Rent A Car
Locations in Fisher Island
Recent reviews
BestWay Auto Rentals
1 location in Fisher Island
BestWay Auto Rentals
Locations in Fisher Island
Recent reviews
Rent Max
1 location in Fisher Island
Rent Max
Locations in Fisher Island
Recent reviews
Silvercar
1 location in Fisher Island
Silvercar
Locations in Fisher Island
Recent reviews
99 travelers who rented a car in Fisher Island gave the car agency they used an average rating of 6.8

Car rental locations in or near Fisher Island

Good to know

Most popular agency

Hertz

Most popular car type

Economy

Average price

$37/day

Good deal

$32/day

When to book a rental car in Fisher Island

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Car rental insurance in Fisher Island

Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) & Theft Protection Waiver

Some Fisher Island car providers already include Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) and Theft Protection Waiver into the rental price but not all of them. We recommend always be aware of your coverage when renting a car in in Fisher Island.

Deductible

Keep in mind that car rental insurances often have a deductible clause, which is the amount you’ll have to pay if something happens during the time of your rental. If you want to avoid unwanted surprises, you should consider adding a no-deductible option to your Fisher Island car rental.

Top tips for renting a car in Fisher Island

  • 25% of our users found rental cars in Fisher Island for $32 or less
  • Economy rental cars in Fisher Island are around 20% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about renting a car in Fisher Island

  • Some car rental companies in Fisher Island which have updated their car rental health and safety policies due to COVID-19 to make sure vehicles are clean and disinfected include Hertz, Budget and Thrifty

  • On average a rental car in Fisher Island costs $37 per day.

  • The average gas price in Fisher Island is $3.63 per gallon over the past 30 days. Filling up a gas tank costs between $44 and $58, depending on the car size.

  • Economy (Hyundai Accent or similar) is the most frequently booked rental car type in Fisher Island.

  • Car rental companies onsite at Miami airport include Right Cars, Sixt, Fox, Easirent, U-Save, Dollar, Hertz, GREEN MOTION, Thrifty and Budget.

  • Car rental companies that offer shuttle or pick-up services from Miami airport to off-airport locations include Right Cars, Sixt, Fox, Easirent, U-Save, Dollar, Hertz, Thrifty, Budget, and Alamo.

  • Take a look at our extensive car rental location map to find the best rental cars near you.

  • A Economy car rental in Fisher Island costs $31 per day, on average.

  • A Compact car rental in Fisher Island costs $37 per day, on average.

  • A Intermediate car rental in Fisher Island costs $41 per day, on average.

  • In Fisher Island, cars are most frequently rented at Right Cars Miami International Airport 4005 North West 28th Street (8 miles from city center).

  • On average a rental car in Fisher Island costs $260 per week ($37 per day).

  • On average a rental car in Fisher Island costs $1,113 per month ($37 per day).

  • Finding the right price, understanding the add-ons and staying up to date with policy changes can be a challenge. That’s why KAYAK has produced the ultimate guide to renting a car to help you cut though the jargon and make the right choice for your rental car. Find tips and insights for how to book your rental, what car rental insurance you’ll need, how to deal with a car rental agency and what extra fees to expect (and avoid!).