Fisher Island car rentals

Compare hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Fisher Island, Florida

Fisher Island, FL
Dec 14 — Dec 21
Same drop-off
Fisher Island, FL
Wed 12/14
Noon
Wed 12/21
Noon

Fisher Island car rental information

Pick-up locationFisher Island
Car types
Rental locations0
Airport locations0

Cheap car rentals in Fisher Island

Mini
Economy
Compact
Intermediate
Standard
Full-size
Luxury
Minivan
Passenger van
SUV
Commercial
Pickup truck
Mini car in Fisher Island
Economy car in Fisher Island
Compact car in Fisher Island
Intermediate car in Fisher Island
Standard car in Fisher Island
Full-size car in Fisher Island
Luxury car in Fisher Island
Minivan car in Fisher Island
Passenger van car in Fisher Island
SUV car in Fisher Island
Commercial car in Fisher Island
Pickup truck car in Fisher Island

Fisher Island car rental reviews and directory

Hertz

6.8

Cleanliness

6.8

Comfort

6.9

Pick-up/Drop-off

6.2

Value for money

7.2

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

530 Collins Ave

+1 786 276 1121

Monday08:00 - 16:00
Tuesday08:00 - 16:00
Wednesday08:00 - 16:00
Thursday08:00 - 16:00
Friday08:00 - 16:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

2.4 Mediocre

Nov 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

Hertz overbooked its reservations. On the morning of pickup, the staff told us there were no cars available for the 6 people waiting with confirmed reservations. Took them about 2 hours to scramble to find other cars for us. It wasn't the fault of the staff at the location, but of Hertz Corporate overbooking their vehicles.

10.0 Excellent

Aug 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

Prompt quick and reliable service

9.6 Excellent

Aug 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

I think the car rental place closing at 5 on Monday is ridiculous. Everything else was great.

2.0 Mediocre

Jun 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

My debit card was alittle damaged from the back that it wouldn’t swipe they didn’t NOT want to Type in my information and basically we’re no help. I had to walk up and down south beach with my bags looking for another car rental place.

2.0 Mediocre

May 2019

KAYAK

Pros:

Nothing

Cons:

Well at least you had to give me the possibility to rent the car.

8.0 Excellent

Apr 2019

KAYAK

Pros:

Easy process to pickup and drop-off.

Cons:

I was given a midsize car instead of the full-size I had reserved.

1 out of 8

Sixt

8.5

Excellent

10 reviews
Best rated

Cleanliness

9.6

Comfort

8.7

Pick-up/Drop-off

8.3

Value for money

8.3

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

701 5th St

+1 888 749 8227

Monday09:00 - 17:00
Tuesday09:00 - 17:00
Wednesday09:00 - 17:00
Thursday09:00 - 17:00
Friday09:00 - 17:00
Saturday09:00 - 17:00
Sunday09:00 - 17:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

10.0 Excellent

Apr 2021

KAYAK

Pros:

Staff was very helpful and detailed

Cons:

Everything was perfect.

5.2 Okay

Jun 2020

KAYAK

Pros:

Drop off was easy and a relief. Vehicle was clean.

Cons:

I ordered a luxury, they had none. I paid for a Mercedes SUV Luxury vehicle. I was on hold for over 90 minutes (screen shot of call) when I tried to complain. I received a Jeep Grand Cherokee. And 25 dollars off my bill. They wanted to refund my debit card I paid with 2 weeks prior to my reservation. Then charge it to a major credit card. I asked why charged and refunded. They then Claimed I didn't read terms and conditions where it explains everything. I was not the only client they did this to while i was there. I wasn't the only one Sixt did this to that day. They didn't have someone elses luxury vehicle who had prepaid and scheduled to be picked up and already paid for. They bate you for what you want online then switch with shitty model and take off a very small inconvenience "sorry" while charging you for tolls and extra insurances. Scam will not use sixt again. Ever.

4.0 Okay

Apr 2022

KAYAK
Like: got a car, the car was in good driving condition, clean. Didn’t like: The car pickup is 2 blocks walking distance from the rental office. There were 2 clerks and 8 people in line. I was standing for 40 minutes before I was able to approach the counter.

10.0 Excellent

Apr 2022

KAYAK
Very good service

1 out of 2

Budget

7.0

Cheapest deal
Most popular

Cleanliness

7.1

Comfort

7.2

Pick-up/Drop-off

7.4

Value for money

6.7

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations
from $52/day

Locations in Fisher Island

959 West Avenue, Suite 6

+1 305 674 8486

Monday08:00 - 16:00
Tuesday08:00 - 16:00
Wednesday08:00 - 16:00
Thursday08:00 - 16:00
Friday08:00 - 16:00
Saturday09:00 - 17:00
Sunday09:00 - 17:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

6.0 Good

Dec 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

The woman at the pick up counter was wonderful and did a great job. The car itself was not clean inside and there were even stains on the seats.

2.0 Mediocre

Aug 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

Kayak Allowed me to make a reservation but when I arrived budget did not have any cars available to rent so why doesn’t KAYAK allow a reservation to be made if the facility has no cars available. This happens over and over again with other car rental agencies booked via KAYAK

3.2 Mediocre

Apr 2018

KAYAK

Cons:

File guage didn’t work. Hard to refuel.

10.0 Excellent

Feb 2018

KAYAK

Pros:

Service

Cons:

N/A

2.8 Mediocre

Oct 2017

KAYAK

Pros:

Nothing

Cons:

They took out extra money because of their mistake and after they did not return the full amount. I will never again take the car in Budget. In the Budget - budgetary service ...

2.0 Mediocre

Apr 2017

KAYAK

Cons:

No car! Owner apologetic but did not help our situation.

1 out of 4

Payless

3.0

Mediocre

5 reviews

Cleanliness

2.0

Comfort

3.2

Pick-up/Drop-off

3.6

Value for money

3.6

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

959 West Avenue

+1 305 674 0399

Monday08:00 - 16:00
Tuesday08:00 - 16:00
Wednesday08:00 - 16:00
Thursday08:00 - 16:00
Friday08:00 - 16:00
Saturday09:00 - 17:00
Sunday09:00 - 17:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

2.0 Mediocre

Jul 2020

KAYAK

Cons:

Booked a reservation and location was closed, unable to pick up a vehicle and unable to obtain refund via car rental company or the third party site for the resevation.

7.2 Good

Jul 2019

KAYAK

Pros:

Manager at the desk was excellent!!!! Super fast and friendly

Cons:

Car was not cleaned between rentals and filled will paper and packing supplies

2.0 Mediocre

Feb 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

You made a reservation for a company that doesn’t work out of that location anymore so when I went to get the car they did not accept the reservation so I had to make a walk-in reservation with them at twice the rate because I didn’t have a choice.

2.0 Mediocre

Jan 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

I was given a reservation for a car rental from a location and company that was no longer in business was there. I was given a reservation for a car in Payless rental car but when I went to the location it was a Budget rental car and they said they do not accept reservations from Payless.

2.0 Mediocre

Jan 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

they did not have system so could not rent the car!

1 out of 2

Enterprise

2.0

Mediocre

8 reviews

Cleanliness

3.0

Comfort

2.0

Pick-up/Drop-off

2.0

Value for money

2.0

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

1000 5th St Ste 100

+1 305 538 4883

Monday08:00 - 16:00
Tuesday08:00 - 16:00
Wednesday08:00 - 16:00
Thursday08:00 - 16:00
Friday08:00 - 16:00
Saturday09:00 - 17:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

2.0 Mediocre

Oct 2020

KAYAK

Pros:

Nothing. They didn’t have any cars for us to take and left us stranded.

Cons:

Everything. They didn’t have any cars for us to take and left us stranded. The girl was rude and didn’t communicate well as to how she was trying to fix the problem. We ended up leaving the location and going with a rental car down the street.

2.0 Mediocre

Oct 2020

KAYAK

Pros:

Nothing.

Cons:

Lady at the desk was incredibly rude and unhelpful. Reserved a convertible. Not only did they not have a convertible, but they actually didn’t have ANY cars available at the time we reserved. And we had a tour booked that we were trying to make. After an hour they told us that they’d located a car but that it was getting an oil change and therefore may take another hour. So we canceled, ubered to Budget, and got a car on the spot.

2.0 Mediocre

Apr 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

I had booked the car for 9.00am. at 11.00 was not yet available, I had to cancel and cancel everything.

2.0 Mediocre

Dec 2019

KAYAK

Cons:

I’ve come to rent agency, and there are no any cars available.

2.0 Mediocre

Dec 2018

KAYAK

Cons:

This was an awful experience. Showed up with a reservation, and after waiting in an empty office for 20 min, someone finally showed up and said they were completely backed up and didn’t have any cars available whatsoever. 13 groups of people were waiting ahead of me who had been there for hours waiting. We had a 2 day car rental, and they said they couldn’t guarantee a car by tomorrow. What’s the point of a reservation if they don’t give you a car? They shouldn’t have given us a reservation if they didn’t have cars available because we could have at least rented from another company. We had to lyft the rest of the weekend, which was a pain because we have newborns and car seats.

2.0 Mediocre

Apr 2022

KAYAK
We booked a convertible but then didn't have it so we got a soccer mom SUV. That blew out entire road trip fun.

1 out of 2

ACO Rent A Car

No score is available

Cleanliness

-

Comfort

-

Pick-up/Drop-off

-

Value for money

-

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

910 Collins Ave.

+1 305 733 0967

Opening times not available

View deals

Filters

No reviews available

BestWay Auto Rentals

No score is available

Cleanliness

-

Comfort

-

Pick-up/Drop-off

-

Value for money

-

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

1000 5th Street

Opening times not available

View deals

Filters

No reviews available

Rent A Car 4 Less Miami

No score is available

Cleanliness

-

Comfort

-

Pick-up/Drop-off

-

Value for money

-

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

524 Washington Ave

Opening times not available

View deals

Filters

No reviews available

Rent Max

No score is available

Cleanliness

-

Comfort

-

Pick-up/Drop-off

-

Value for money

-

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

1000 5th Street

305-526-2129

Opening times not available

View deals

Filters

No reviews available

Silvercar

No score is available

Cleanliness

-

Comfort

-

Pick-up/Drop-off

-

Value for money

-

One location in Fisher Island

Show locations

Locations in Fisher Island

1100 West Ave

+1 855 359 2227

Monday00:00 - 00:00
Tuesday00:00 - 00:00
Wednesday00:00 - 00:00
Thursday00:00 - 00:00
Friday00:00 - 00:00
Saturday00:00 - 00:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00
View deals

Filters

No reviews available

102 travelers who rented a car in Fisher Island gave the car agency they used an average rating of 6.4

Car rental locations in or near Fisher Island

Good to know

Most popular agency

Thrifty

Most popular car type

Compact

Average price

$38/day

Good deal

$38/day

When to book a rental car in Fisher Island

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Top tips for renting a car in Fisher Island

  • 25% of our users found rental cars in Fisher Island for $38 or less
  • Compact rental cars in Fisher Island are around 50% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about renting a car in Fisher Island