extra charges drove the price up
Pros: The staff was friendly. Unlimited miles included in rental.
Cons: Extra charge for additional driver (my wife) $13/day. Extra charge for day I didn't use it, just because I returned it after hours (even though the parking garage ticket indicated the time I returned it). Apparently this was a policy change once Hertz bought Dollar. Enterprise didn't charge me for an additional driver or for time not used. Also, Dollar miscalculated the charge for the tank of gas. The car itself (a Mazda 2) was fine, but the key was inconvenient -- no remote locking, only the driver door had a keyhole, and to unlock other doors you had to reach inside to hit an unlock button (no option to, say, double turn the key in the door to unlock all doors).
Lastly, while very close to the PATH station as the crow flies, it is a bit of a hike from the station as the human walks. No shuttle was offered.