Book Advantage car rentals in New York

Tue 5/23 Pick-up
Fri 5/26 Drop-off
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none

Reviews for Advantage in New York

  • All reviews 100%
4.1/10 Okay
Based on 131 reviews
  • 3.6
  • 3.8
  • 3.0
  • 3.5

Recent reviews

Most recent
    2.0 Poor
    May 16 2017
    If there were a lower rating I would give it.
    Pros: Nothing staff is rude. The absolute worst.
    Cons: I picked up my car WITH my car insurance information (which they require in NYC. Totally bogus. No other renter requires that) my insurence had no experation date... with out the date I wasn't allowed to rent. I asked "how do we move forward?" The desk worker literally threw my credit card and lincense at me and said "come back with an experation." I rented from Enterprise. And it was great. I would NEVER rent here. This was my third time; all in different states. Horrible experiences. Shame on me, I guess.
    8.0 Good
    Supplier Choice
    May 15 2017
    Cons: There needs to be a BIG warning that you must HAVE your own insurance in order to rent from Advantage or be from another country with plane tickets for arriving and departing. Being a resident of NYC I don't have a car - like most - so I was not alerted to this fact, even through the rental process. It was a shock when I got to the counter.
    4.8 Okay
    Supplier Choice
    May 9 2017
    Pros: Car was decent
    Cons: Could not drop off at another airport location unless I paid another $1,500! It was also really annoying to get to from the airport and it took more than 30 min to get to the airport after dropping off the car.
    2.8 Mediocre
    May 7 2017
    Waste of my time.
    Pros: Nothing
    Cons: Teller at JFK acted like I should be privileged to be renting from them, and further that I should have known that there was a miniscule byline that required insurance. I provided insurance, and then was told that a NEW YORK STATE DMV DOCUMENT was not a valid document...even with a passport.... Pay an extra 8$ and rent elsewhere so this company can fail like they inevitably will. Inflexible and useless staff.

Where can I find Advantage car rentals in New York?

45-01 20th Ave, Advantage car rentals


45-01 20th Ave


(800) 777-5500