Book Advantage car rentals in New York

Mon 4/24 Pick-up
Thu 4/27 Drop-off
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none

Reviews for Advantage in New York

  • All reviews 100%
4.1/10 Okay
Based on 125 reviews
  • 3.5
  • 3.7
  • 3.0
  • 3.5

Recent reviews

Most recent
    4.0 Mediocre
    Apr 16 2017
    Cons: As a resident of NYC area, the "fine print" about 150 miles per day maximum was a surprise. The pay before hand was not useful. The car was rented due to an auto accident, and the initial contract for a few days was prior to learning about the insurer paying for the car. The extension of the rental could not be done through the insurer. The abrupt phone call on Thursday April 13th in the afternoon about the immediate need to return the car was highly inconvenient. When I called he 718 # back, full voicemail. Where was no explanation for this demand. If the car had a safety issue, why did Advantage rent it to me? if the temp plates were due on 19 April, why the return on the 13th? if there is a reason for this demand, why not explain? The car had a "low tire" warning, left rear, but there tire appeared to be fully inflated.
    5.6 Okay
    Apr 9 2017
    False adverisement
    Pros: Returning the car was a breeze.
    Cons: Unlimited mileage advertised but it wasn't the case when I went to pick up the car. Unexpected policy about insurance when you are from another borough within the same city (which I had never heard of before). I was told to provide proof of FULL insurance coverage OR a round trip ticket. So I not only needed to provide a letter stating that my personal car was fully insured but I also ended up purchasing their own insurance. This is a car I needed within a few hours in order to start my orientation week with my new job and the rep clearly stated that she couldn't give me the car if I didn't provide the info. Had a relative not been with me, I would've had to return home empty ended after traveling 23 miles with traffic. Never again!
    2.8 Mediocre
    Apr 9 2017
    Slow service dirty car!
    Cons: The employees were friendly but inefficient and the service was poor. One person was doing all the work and the two others we saw didn't seem to know what to do next. When we finally got the car, the car was not cleaned thoroughly. The driver's seat and the steering wheel was covered in food.
    2.0 Poor
    Apr 3 2017
    they turned me away
    Pros: nothing
    Cons: they said because I am a New Yorker I had to have my own insurance, but that wasn't made readily apparent in any of the documents or emails I received. I was forced to rent from someone else same day, which was incredibly expensive.

Where can I find Advantage car rentals in New York?

45-01 20th Ave, Advantage car rentals


45-01 20th Ave


(800) 777-5500