New York Hotels near Carnegie Hall

Expensive small rooms

Basic Courtyard- clean, large enough room by NY standards, great location

Old single pane windows allowed in even more noise than I am used to in NYC. Courtyards are also my last choice among Marriott brands since they essentially provide nothing for anyone with Marriott Rewards status, unlike all the other Marriott brands.

Easy walking distance to area attractions like Madison Square Garden, theater district, Empire State Building and numerous restaurants. Very clean room with plenty of outlets, and friendly front desk. Very nice, and rare, open outdoor space in front of hotel.

A bit disorganized with the luggage holding process and the lobby lounge should be open later during the summer. The hotel has very nice outdoor space which is rare for hotels in that busy area and could get better use. Got back from concert at 12:30 and had to look for a bar/pub to have a night cap.

Clean, Good location

Broken front door.

Cleaning staff came too early in the morning

They people were great

Lack of coffee maker / limited to one coffee per day..

Very nice staff

206 should be a storage closet! Nestled between two fire doors, starting at 4am, the two fire doors slam prohibiting any sleep!!

Location was great. The subway station was only half a block away. You can get anywhere in the City very quickly and easily. Herald Square is a neat place as well. Lots going on at night and day. Bed was very comfortable. My only complaint is that the breakfast area is too small - we were never able to sit and eat.

good location close to all attractions, front desk staff were nice, room was clean, included breakfast

When arrived to our room, a note was on our headboard: "Duvet covers & sheets are clean for your arrival" I sure hope so don't all customers need to have clean sheets and covers? Only 2 elevators, working staff would use it all the time to go between floors, waiting time too long. Breakfast are very salty, buffet not refilled fast enough. Hotel does not give Air miles points

This guest did not leave comments about this hotel.

Uncomfortable sofa bed No 'do not disturb' placard so housekeeping opened our door at 8:30 am despite it being locked. Front desk was apologetic. The room should have had a placard.

The room was very clean and cozy, The shower had great pressure. The staff were so kind. The lounge was cozy and good happy hour prices. The location is great.

Noisy, Windows need some sound proofing and insulation

Location was excellent. Walking distance to pretty much everything in Manhatten. Reception was very good.

There was one small roll of toilet paper and no soap in the bathroom. Dusty bed lamp with hard to find switch.

They don't have bathroom inside the room, no free internet, no parking, no breakfast and they tell on they website they have everything, it's a lie. We need split a restroom with another people like in a hostel, it was the worst.

- Friendly and helpful staff - Small but clean room, comfortable bed - Well-appointed and nice ambiance - Within easy walking distance of Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, Times Square, Empire State Building, Grand Central Station, and other midtown sights, as well as shopping and good restaurants

Disappointed that the rooftop garden was closed for renovation

Nice location. Room was small, but clean and updated. Hotel itself is a bit dated and doudy.

Check in and out the staff were pleasant. Comfortable beds.

Too focused on being trendy. Was advertised as a 4-5 star. More like a 3-4 star No coffee makers in room.

My husband and I were traveling with our 2 adult children and their traveling companions, so we booked 3 rooms. All rooms were spacious and comfortable. Decor was trendy, with high end amenities. We loved the rooftop bar and had a great meal at the attached restaurant. Location was perfect. Overall, a great stay.

Some of the furniture in the room was showing some wear. And the desk chair was the only chair in the room. Also, the closet was very small. Not enough space to hang our clothes and coats.

Roof Top Bar, location

Expensive, small room, mattress made loud noises getting in and out of bed. No room service, no food except after 6PM.

the friendly and helpful staff and a very central location

we liked it all

Cleanliness and very good included breakfast

Front desk staff could not find reservation so had to stand there for over 15 minutes!! NEver did correct incorrect spelling of name so no one could find me during my stay..... Discrepancy between morning check out bill and (higher) amount charged to Discover card!! WIll have to waste time on follow up call

We prefer Marriott hotels and this one did not disappoint. It is so centrally located, just a few blocks from Bryant Park, Macy's Herald Square and Times Square, as well as Fifth Avenue and Radio City. The breakfast was great, lots of choices with eggs, yogurt, muffins, bagels and more. The staff are very welcoming and helpful. Would recommend and would stay again on next visit to the City, especially at Christmas.

Only that no coffee available in lobby during day.

The location was great. Just a short walk to a lot of places - Bryant Park, Times Square, the Empire State Building, Times Square, and Radio City Music Hall. There was a nice breakfast each morning with eggs, bacon or sausage, yogurt, hard-boiled eggs, bagels, pastries, fruit, and more.

Brand new hotel with very attentive staff. Even though the rooms are typically small (it is New York) the layout was done good enough to make it comfortable and still fit a king size bed. Really liked the large walk- in shower.

Would have been nice to have a mini fridge. Only ice machine was in the basement.

We stayed in a large clean studio room for just two nights. It was a good experience but the room wasn't as large as I thought it would be. For example, when the sofa bed is pulled out there isn't any room to walk between it and the full/queen bed in the room. The pull out couch bed was as uncomfortable as we expected it would be, but after our long NY city days, we didn't care. Breakfast was plentiful in options, but so packed with people one of us had to stand to eat. Get there early I guess! Elevators were just as bad; the general advice was to go up to get down.  Clean room. Prompt service. We'd stay again.

Excellent TImes Square location for weekend stay .

Decor was great, rooms were clean and mini bar was stocked with great snacks at reasonable prices ($2 per soda).

Rooms were small but this isn't unheard of for Manhattan.

The staff was very friendly and professional. The even remembered us the next day. Evan was wonderful, positive and up beat. Everyone was very helpful, even moved us when our AC was malfunctioning.

Rooms were kind of small but then we were in the a limited amount of space as far as the city was concerned.

Nice interior

All staff Ive come across felt like security. They dont respond to greetings. When they selectively ask to see your room keycard to enter the hotel and you see the people in front of you stroll right in while you get "carded" almost everytime...Im a well groomed mid 20's asian business man on vacation what more do you want? And in the heart of korea-town no less! I avoided the staff for the rest of my stay due to their less than friendly disposition and most times they seemed too busy to talk to you because they are allll on their phones textingg! Mainly speaking of night staff. For such a historic Landmark of a Hotel the staff certainly takes away from its authenticity,beauty and glamour. As far as the rooms go everthing seemed fairly clean and nice. Only issue was the brown water I had to shower in and the air condition wasnt working the first day but their engineering staff promptly fixed the A/C unit.

Nice hotel

Check in process was BAD Booked via Kayak and they did not have my reservation I had a confirmation # Took almost an hour to resolve

I liked that it is right next to Penn Station and just two blocks from the venue where the concert I was there to see.

The bathroom was very small, the TV was at least 15 years old and about 30ft from the bed.

I generally don't expect too nice of a place at the low rate...but the carpet was sticky and the beds were sticky and damp. None of the outlets worked. The staff was nice, but not the most accommodating. Although, in their defense, there really wasn't much they could do - it really just needs to be renovated.

We had to wear shoes the entire time we were in our room, because the carpet was damp and sticky. Had to order fresh comforters everyday due to the beds being so damp and sticky. Did not look forward to going back to our hotel each night after our long days in the city. Needs renovation.

Cleaning was horrible.

Unbeatable location, amazing staff nice room

No view

Breakfast was great!! But staff was great and overall stay was good!

Wifi and phone reception was horrible. AC was loud and had restroom problems with toilet.

The staff was excellent and really helpful in helping us find locations and how to get there.

This hotel has the loudest air conditioner I have ever heard in my life! It worked great, but was so loud that we had to turn it off to get some sleep.

Location, staff, cleanliness, value, view out window (Empire State Building), mattress comfort

Toilet size (space between sink and wall), shower water pressure, hard water

New furniture

The room was a very good value for the price, very clean, great staff, comfortable, great location, rooftop bar has an amazing view, good drink selection with low drink prices and just a cool little spot.

There was noisy construction next door going on 24 hours a day, the breakfast less than I expected and a continental breakfast not a hot breakfast.

Room was reasonably priced and big for NYC

the elevator beeps were very loud, and it also made grinding noises. My room was right across from the elevator, so it was annoying.

Our check in/out and all interactions with staff were very positive. Breakfast was good, a hot waffle, pastry, egg, or potatoes, plus juice, cereal and hot drinks. The two doubles in one tiny room were adequate. No tub only shower and the TV/cable was the bare minimum. Complimentary internet was adequate. Overall I recommend and would stay again.

Horrible place, breakfast awful with little nutritious value. It would have better to eat at McDonald's ! This is overpriced even for Manhattan. If parking is available, it will cost you an average of $50 per night. I don't think the bedding had been changed for me after the prior customers had checked-out.

I love this hotel.

The tech needs a minor facelift. I love the USB ports in the plug ins and alarm, but the Apple connection stuff is a decade old and Apple always changes their stuff just enough that you have to keep upgrading random toys like iPads, which sucks because even an old iPad can do some basic stuff like watch Netflix and control your AirPlay Spotify and those things, which is way more valuable than if you buy an app for a buck and you play it for a week and then check a month later and its third on your list for storage used. So certain things I've had to upgrade and now I'm a plugin short, which is a super first world problem sounding issue. Just sayin', the whole thing seems fishy to me. This hotel is nice. I'd absolutely stay there again, and there's a Blue Bottel coffee like 3 doors down, which is nice because New Yorkers are an amazing group of people that I love, but they don't drink good coffee. There are Starbucks everywhere and they always taste burned (burnt?) to me. Blue Bottle is a bit pretentious, but when you're a great coffee in a great city, you're winning. Also, Bryant Park is across the street from the hotel, and they do a bunch of cool little concerts and stuff in that park, and they keep it clean and there is a solid brunch place in there and a Grill. Oh, yeah, and the elevators at the hotel are some weird cross between a coffin and a bad 70's porno shoot. It's really dark and there may be velvet on the walls, but it's too dark to tell. If you're in there with another person, it's a little tight. A person or two with luggage? Really tight. That's a hard one to fix, though. You'd be out of commission the entire time because it's the only way up. Maybe just brighten it a little bit. The bar downstairs used to be solid and I bet still is, but I didn't go down there this trip. It is Friday night and I just wrote that. That is not a good life sign.

the location is great because I love Bryant Park.

Old hotel, but redone kind of modernish. They should have left it old. We had a tiny room that looked out on ugly air conditioners from the other building. I had always dreamed of staying there but was very disappointed .